Columbia Heights School District — Transcript

Thursday, October 1, 2026

School Board Elections & Voter Education

Defining Equity and Identifying Equity Actions

Aftermath of Operation Metro Surge

Operating Levy and District Financial Needs

Preparing Students for AI and Technology

Student Safety and Parental Concerns Regarding Diversity

School Safety Measures and Preventing Violence

Budgetary Priorities and Spending Reductions

Votes (7)

Define Equity and Identify Equity Actions

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates discussed the definition of equity, uniformly agreeing it means providing individualized resources for success. Kristen Craig emphasized belonging, LGBTQIA+ support, and student voice. Adam Davis expressed concern over current educational outcomes and state control over budgets. Laura Palmer highlighted systemic barrier removal and district success with English learners. Jessica Maderas stressed diverse staff recruitment, culturally responsive curriculum, and mental health support, while also noting that test scores are only one part of student achievement.

Response to Operation Metro Surge and its Aftermath

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates universally condemned the methods of Operation Metro Surge, recognizing the deep trauma it caused students and families. They praised the community and district for providing support and safety. Jessica Maderas highlighted the ongoing impacts, including learning and language loss, and the need for continued advocacy and wraparound services. Kristen Craig underscored the link between student safety and learning, advocating for sustained social-emotional and mental health support.

Stance on Operating Levy and Explaining Financial Needs

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates expressed strong support for the operating levy. Jessica Maderas and Laura Palmer detailed the significant state funding cuts (around $3.5 to $5 million) and the district's history of cutting over $7 million in the past decade, stressing the levy's necessity to serve current students and avoid deeper classroom impacts. Kristen Craig linked the levy to fully funding education, special education, and the Minnesota Read Act. Adam Davis supported the levy's reasonableness but raised concerns about the broader tax burden on residents from other local government entities and opposed a separate constitutional amendment regarding school funds.

Preparing Students for AI and Preventing Misuse

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates addressed the challenges and opportunities of AI. Jessica Maderas and Laura Palmer emphasized the need to learn alongside students, utilize AI's benefits (e.g., for multi-language learners), and put safeguards in place to preserve critical thinking. Adam Davis expressed concern about over-reliance potentially eroding fundamental research skills and cited low current academic proficiency scores. Kristen Craig focused on teaching critical thinking and media literacy, and adapting teaching methods to ensure authentic student learning in an AI-pervasive world.

Safe Environments for Diverse Students and Parental Concerns

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates affirmed the importance of creating safe, welcoming, and affirming environments for all students, including those with diverse faith beliefs and sexualities (LGBTQIA+). Laura Palmer specifically condemned policies that institutionalize cruelty and highlighted the high self-harm rates among LGBTQ+ youth. Candidates agreed on open communication with parents regarding curriculum and resources, but Kristen Craig specified that parental choices should not impinge on the rights or safety of other students or staff. Jessica Maderas cited positive climate survey results indicating high feelings of safety and belonging among students and parents.

Increased School Safety Measures

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates emphasized that effective school safety goes beyond physical security to foster a sense of belonging and provide robust social-emotional and mental health support. Kristen Craig linked belonging and social-emotional learning directly to preventing violence, citing research. Adam Davis highlighted the importance of a welcoming environment where students feel heard and have positive relationships with staff and School Liaison Officers. Laura Palmer and Jessica Maderas stressed preventing student isolation and building connections as key to true safety and preventing tragedies.

Top Three Budgetary Priorities and Potential Cuts

No formal action taken as this is a candidate forum.

Candidates struggled to name specific cuts due to years of previous reductions, emphasizing that there's 'no meat left on the bone.' Laura Palmer prioritized busing and classroom funding, advocating for passing the levy. Jessica Maderas noted the district's history of cuts and the need to pass the levy, use fund balance, and advocate legislatively. Kristen Craig framed priorities through the lens of 'all belong, all succeed, and opportunity for all' from the strategic plan. Adam Davis, while acknowledging budget limitations, questioned bus routes outside the district and warned against shortsighted cuts like previous band program reductions.

Notable Quotes (21)

Um what I always talk about with had talked about with my students is that equity is not everybody getting the same thing but everybody getting what they need in order to succeed.

Define Equity and Identify Equity Actions

75% of our budget is allocated in some way. The state dictates how we go about spending it and we have a lot of unique and diverse u uh needs in Colombia Heights and we're not able to uh address that.

Define Equity and Identify Equity Actions

Um, MCA's I think about if you think about academic achievement as a book, MCAs are really a page in that book. And if you don't look at the rest of the story, it's really hard to understand what's happening there.

Define Equity and Identify Equity Actions

but wherever you are on that uh what happened during operation uh Metro Surge, you can't uh justify um the methods that they used and and coming onto school property or being near school property, following kids, um you know, going after some of of our students here. It's just not the way to do it.

Response to Operation Metro Surge and its Aftermath

I mentioned I have a spouse who teaches in the district and when he was first teaching, not in this district, but his first couple years teaching, I we had I bought him a kit for his classroom, a rope ladder, a doors stopper, bandages, and the reality of thinking that he might actually need to use that is terrifying.

Response to Operation Metro Surge and its Aftermath

One thing that I know for sure is that if students don't feel safe, students don't learn. And so there was a lot of learning that could not happen even after um the surge sort of uh died down.

Response to Operation Metro Surge and its Aftermath

When we lose as a district almost $4 million in a district our size, that's not something that we're able to reallocate or cut our way out of. We talk about trying to keep cuts outside of classrooms or far away from the classroom as possible. and we can't continue to do that.

Stance on Operating Levy and Explaining Financial Needs

I am in support of that because I feel like that uh their ask is reasonable. What I will say in the broader picture, and this is where I always come back to for people, is those that are on the fixed incomes, those that are in low incomes, I worry about because while we're asking for this, and we have to ask, the cities and the counties don't have to ask you.

Stance on Operating Levy and Explaining Financial Needs

Just to give you kind of like a global perspective, that's like what it costs to like the staffing for an entire school in our district. That's what we're talking about when we're talking about this this amount of funds.

Stance on Operating Levy and Explaining Financial Needs

AI is increasingly being used in the workforce and our students on some level will be expected to know how to manage that technology. At the same time, um AI as we know uh creates uh many concerns around uh intellectual property. This the the stealing of intellectual property.

Preparing Students for AI and Preventing Misuse

But if you're a parent out there and you're looking for a school and say well which school should I pick? This is what worries me. Uh this year Columbia Heights High School math proficiency is 9.9%. Reading 25. science 8.7.

Preparing Students for AI and Preventing Misuse

And thinking critically is going to be the thing that's going to get them very far. And AI can be that thing that can assist that, but it also could be that thing that that um disables them from being able to access those parts of their brain.

Preparing Students for AI and Preventing Misuse

when we have threequarters of our district uh budget that we can't even move around, we need to tell our state legislators, so those that are running for state house and state senate, ask them, ask your governor candidate, will you give an independent school district more flexibility to actually allow us to do the diversity that we actually want to do in our district? Let us be independent.

Safe Environments for Diverse Students and Parental Concerns

I fundamentally do not understand the desire to use legal protections as a shield to be cruel, to bully children or to pass policies that institutionalize cruelty. While we failed when we fail to support our students, the consequences are devastating. It is a heartbreaking reality that LGBTQ plus youth face some of the highest rates of self harm in our country.

Safe Environments for Diverse Students and Parental Concerns

Our students and our parents uh continuously uh report on all of our climate surveys that they feel safe at school, that they feel that they belong at school, and not just a majority. Um, over 90 95% uh in some cases depending on the population you're looking at.

Safe Environments for Diverse Students and Parental Concerns

What I know from research and from my experience as an educator is that creating spaces of belonging um providing social emotional learning opportunities to support students um understanding emotions, understanding how to talk about them, identify them, be able to um empathize with other people, be able to talk out um problems are going is that's going to be a much greater um safety measure than armed officers or any of those things in a school building.

Increased School Safety Measures

I think it's also important that uh they have a good relationship with the school leaison officer. Uh because it's important that uh students that their only interaction uh with the police officer is not when they're having um when they're in trouble, but that uh that they can uh have uh that relationship with uh our community, including our our uh our police in a productive way.

Increased School Safety Measures

I do believe that the best way to protect our buildings and protect our kids is making sure that no one is left to struggle in the shadows.

Increased School Safety Measures

We really do need to pass this this levy coming up here. It's going to be tough enough to trim a million dollars out of the budget even when it passes. Um, so I I can't I can't say much more. This really is a hard question because there really there isn't there isn't much left meat left. There's no meat left on the bone.

Top Three Budgetary Priorities and Potential Cuts

Insufficient funding impacts everything from academic growth and success, the interventions we can provide, class sizes, curricular offerings, uh workload and burnout of our staff and recruitment and retention to the district. So it really does impact every single part of our mission and everything we're trying to advance.

Top Three Budgetary Priorities and Potential Cuts

any kind of a cut that I'd be looking at, I would make sure that it wouldn't be shortsighted. So, I know Laura was mentioning about uh band and I remember and she's been on the board long enough to remember we've had at one point we did a fifth grade band uh cut and that was shortsighted. Uh it destroyed the viability of the music program for years after that.

Top Three Budgetary Priorities and Potential Cuts

Ordinances & Resolutions (5)

Minnesota Read ActOther

A legislative act that Kristen Craig supports for implementation to improve literacy scores.

Operating LevyOther

A ballot question in November for additional funding for the school district, which candidates largely support.

Permanent School Fund Increase / Constitutional AmendmentOther

A ballot question Adam Davis opposes, concerned about removing guarantees and relying on future politicians. Kristen Craig supports it.

Local Literacy PlanPlan

Columbia Heights has a strong plan that Kristen Craig believes will help students make gains related to the Minnesota Read Act.

Strategic Vision and Strategic PlanPlan

Kristen Craig believes budgetary areas should align with and fund the district's strategic vision and plan.

View Source
Columbia Heights School District - Columbia Heights Recorder