Eagan City Council — Transcript

Friday, October 9, 2026

Vision for the City of Eagan

Blue Cross HQ Redevelopment

Metcalf Park Demolition (Former Middle School)

Gopher Resources Lead Smelter and Environmental Concerns

City's Role in ICE Enforcement

Data Center Moratorium and Future Standards

Most Important Unaddressed Issue Facing Eagan

Votes (7)

What is your vision for the city of Eagan?

N/A - Candidate Forum

Candidates outlined their visions for Eagan's future. Paul Bakken focused on fiscal security, infrastructure, and controlled levy increases. Gary Hansen championed innovation, budget transparency, citizen engagement, and addressing housing affordability. Jason Narverud emphasized future generations, thoughtful infrastructure (data centers, housing), and making difficult decisions. Scott Armitage highlighted building community, supporting small businesses, and addressing specific safety concerns like e-scooters.

Since Blue Cross vacated its Eagan headquarters headquarters campus in 2023, two major redevelopment proposals for this site have collapsed. What do you think went wrong, and should the city take a more active role in its redevelopment?

N/A - Candidate Forum

The discussion explored the reasons for failed redevelopment efforts at the former Blue Cross site. Candidates cited issues like lack of community support, unsuitable proposals, and soil conditions. Incumbents emphasized the council's patient approach and current environmental assessment. Challengers called for more clarity, urgency, and specific rezoning considerations from the city to guide future development.

The Metcalf Park development was approved over a year ago, but the vacant former middle school building is still standing and is drawn 216 police calls this year alone, plus a two alarm fire in June that left it unsafe to occupy. City staff have since urged the school district to expedite demolition over life safety concerns, but it is still unresolved. Who pays? As a council member, what would you do to force faster action on demolition and would you support the city stepping in with its own funds, rather than waiting on the district and developer to sort out the bill?

N/A - Candidate Forum

Candidates discussed the unresolved demolition of the former Metcalf Park middle school and associated safety hazards. While acknowledging the property owner (ISD 191) is responsible, there was debate on whether the city should intervene. Most candidates, including incumbent Gary Hansen, opposed direct city funding, emphasizing the district's responsibility. Challenger Scott Armitage voiced strong concern about delayed action potentially leading to serious injury and suggested city involvement, while Jason Narverud advocated for partnership and finding a solution for safety.

Gopher resources lead smelter has been in federal non-attainment status for airborne lead for 16 years. Elevated emissions in early 2025 triggered an Mpca investigation. A $30 million settlement with residents and workers, and a still pending new state in state implementation plan for the area. As a city council member, what responsibility does the city have beyond deferring to Mpca and county oversight? Would you support restricting future residential development or rezoning near the facility until the area achieves attainment status?

N/A - Candidate Forum

Candidates discussed the city's role concerning the Gopher Resources lead smelter's non-attainment status. Most recognized the MPCA's primary regulatory authority, limiting the city's direct intervention. Some supported restricting residential development nearby until attainment status is achieved, while others stressed transparency, data review, and acting as a liaison for affected residents to influence state agencies.

What role do you believe the City of Eagan should play when Ice conducts enforcement activities in the city?

N/A - Candidate Forum

Candidates emphasized the city's commitment to protecting all residents and not collaborating with federal immigration enforcement. The Eagan Police Department's role is to ensure public safety and trust, never asking about immigration status, and not supporting ICE activities, even if it means addressing issues left behind by federal agents.

Eagan was the first city in Minnesota to pass a moratorium on new data center development. As a council member, do you support the moratorium as the right way to study impacts like electricity demand and water use before more data centers are built? When the moratorium expires, what specific standards would standards would you want in place before Eagan allows new data center projects to move forward?

N/A - Candidate Forum

All candidates supported Eagan's moratorium on data center development, recognizing its importance for studying environmental and community impacts. Key standards discussed included addressing water usage, noise, light pollution, 'forever chemicals,' limited employment, and decommissioning processes. There was a consensus on the need to distinguish between older, smaller data centers and new hyperscale facilities, and to carefully consider their location away from residential areas.

What is the most important issue facing Eagan that's not receiving enough attention?

N/A - Candidate Forum

Candidates identified a range of issues they felt were under-addressed. Jason Narverud focused on representation and active decision-making for a changing Eagan. Gary Hansen pointed to ongoing initiatives like Race Equity and Inclusion and Sustainability. Paul Bakken highlighted external threats to local land use authority from the state legislature and the internal organizational culture of the city. Scott Armitage emphasized a general lack of communication with residents and the need for greater public engagement.

Notable Quotes (28)

I would like to lean in, particularly with everything that's going on at the national level, to make sure that our finances are secure, that we have a robust and stable tax base in order to generate the resources to provide the services that our constituents have have come to rely upon.

— Paul Bakken [00:10:29,900]
What is your vision for the city of Eagan?

Part of my vision is we need to figure out ways to make more housing affordable for people who really do want to live and work here.

— Gary Hansen [00:11:51,020]
What is your vision for the city of Eagan?

I want to make sure the fact that we are being really thoughtful about how we think about data centers, how we think about our infrastructure. I want to make sure the fact that we're not getting, um, mesmerized by some of the money that these data centers are throwing at us.

— Jason Narverud [00:13:05,600]
What is your vision for the city of Eagan?

The number one thing for me is really this community aspect and businesses, um, we become a little cookie cutter to me. We don't have a lot of small business owners and this, and this is what's important to me. This is who I am.

— Scott Armitage [00:14:26,540]
What is your vision for the city of Eagan?

In the first two proposals for, uh, Blue Cross property, we have not felt that those were necessarily the right redevelopments for those areas. And we listened to, to the neighbors.

— Gary Hansen [00:17:15,770]
Since Blue Cross vacated its Eagan headquarters headquarters campus in 2023, two major redevelopment proposals for this site have collapsed. What do you think went wrong, and should the city take a more active role in its redevelopment?

I think with any problem that you're trying to solve, you need to be really clear about what problem you're solving. So I think we need to be clear about what do we want for that property.

— Jason Narverud [00:17:51,550]
Since Blue Cross vacated its Eagan headquarters headquarters campus in 2023, two major redevelopment proposals for this site have collapsed. What do you think went wrong, and should the city take a more active role in its redevelopment?

This is a council that's proven to be very patient in its approach towards redevelopment. We don't snap at the first thing that comes up, uh, witness Cedar Grove, that process from start to finish took over ten years to find things that were the right fit.

— Paul Bakken [00:19:35,140]
Since Blue Cross vacated its Eagan headquarters headquarters campus in 2023, two major redevelopment proposals for this site have collapsed. What do you think went wrong, and should the city take a more active role in its redevelopment?

I think that we just need to be a little bit more urgent about it. The topic doesn't seem to come up enough in city council meetings.

— Scott Armitage [00:20:53,990]
Since Blue Cross vacated its Eagan headquarters headquarters campus in 2023, two major redevelopment proposals for this site have collapsed. What do you think went wrong, and should the city take a more active role in its redevelopment?

I think one of the things that it stands out to me is the fact that there's this action that we're playing, this game of who's responsible for this. And I think as a city council member, that's one of our responsibilities, is really asking that question of what's what goal are we trying to accomplish here? And right now, I hear it's around safety, right?

— Jason Narverud [00:22:52,980]
The Metcalf Park development was approved over a year ago, but the vacant former middle school building is still standing and is drawn 216 police calls this year alone, plus a two alarm fire in June that left it unsafe to occupy. City staff have since urged the school district to expedite demolition over life safety concerns, but it is still unresolved. Who pays? As a council member, what would you do to force faster action on demolition and would you support the city stepping in with its own funds, rather than waiting on the district and developer to sort out the bill?

Personally, I would not be in favor of the city stepping in with its own funds to to, to demolish that property. It is the school district's responsibility.

— Gary Hansen [00:24:43,490]
The Metcalf Park development was approved over a year ago, but the vacant former middle school building is still standing and is drawn 216 police calls this year alone, plus a two alarm fire in June that left it unsafe to occupy. City staff have since urged the school district to expedite demolition over life safety concerns, but it is still unresolved. Who pays? As a council member, what would you do to force faster action on demolition and would you support the city stepping in with its own funds, rather than waiting on the district and developer to sort out the bill?

Somebody ends up getting hurt. Um, on a more serious level, we tend to react to things a little bit late. Um, so I do believe that the city could help fund this.

— Scott Armitage [00:25:21,390]
The Metcalf Park development was approved over a year ago, but the vacant former middle school building is still standing and is drawn 216 police calls this year alone, plus a two alarm fire in June that left it unsafe to occupy. City staff have since urged the school district to expedite demolition over life safety concerns, but it is still unresolved. Who pays? As a council member, what would you do to force faster action on demolition and would you support the city stepping in with its own funds, rather than waiting on the district and developer to sort out the bill?

If it gets to the point where the city needs to step in and fill the gap because the school district is not acting, it will do so. But that'll be a pass through cost.

— Paul Bakken [00:26:42,390]
The Metcalf Park development was approved over a year ago, but the vacant former middle school building is still standing and is drawn 216 police calls this year alone, plus a two alarm fire in June that left it unsafe to occupy. City staff have since urged the school district to expedite demolition over life safety concerns, but it is still unresolved. Who pays? As a council member, what would you do to force faster action on demolition and would you support the city stepping in with its own funds, rather than waiting on the district and developer to sort out the bill?

I would support restricting future residential development and rezoning um, near the facility. It is the MPC A's. Um it is their there problem, but it is the city of Egon's responsibility to look out for those homeowners in that area.

— Scott Armitage [00:28:01,810]
Gopher resources lead smelter has been in federal non-attainment status for airborne lead for 16 years. Elevated emissions in early 2025 triggered an Mpca investigation. A $30 million settlement with residents and workers, and a still pending new state in state implementation plan for the area. As a city council member, what responsibility does the city have beyond deferring to Mpca and county oversight? Would you support restricting future residential development or rezoning near the facility until the area achieves attainment status?

This issue in particular has been very frustrating because our hands are tied in terms of what we can do. There is a carve out for issues like that that lie solely with the Mpca, and I cannot stress how frustrating it is to not have influence or control over an issue that's affecting the neighbors who live in our community.

— Paul Bakken [00:29:08,810]
Gopher resources lead smelter has been in federal non-attainment status for airborne lead for 16 years. Elevated emissions in early 2025 triggered an Mpca investigation. A $30 million settlement with residents and workers, and a still pending new state in state implementation plan for the area. As a city council member, what responsibility does the city have beyond deferring to Mpca and county oversight? Would you support restricting future residential development or rezoning near the facility until the area achieves attainment status?

I think the way we build trust in this world is around transparency. And I think that is something that the Eagan City Council can make sure that they do.

— Jason Narverud [00:30:33,750]
Gopher resources lead smelter has been in federal non-attainment status for airborne lead for 16 years. Elevated emissions in early 2025 triggered an Mpca investigation. A $30 million settlement with residents and workers, and a still pending new state in state implementation plan for the area. As a city council member, what responsibility does the city have beyond deferring to Mpca and county oversight? Would you support restricting future residential development or rezoning near the facility until the area achieves attainment status?

There seems to be some misconception from some people about what the city's authority is and being able to shut down gopher resource. Well, we can't just do that. That's the regulatory authority lies with the Mpca.

— Gary Hansen [00:31:59,380]
Gopher resources lead smelter has been in federal non-attainment status for airborne lead for 16 years. Elevated emissions in early 2025 triggered an Mpca investigation. A $30 million settlement with residents and workers, and a still pending new state in state implementation plan for the area. As a city council member, what responsibility does the city have beyond deferring to Mpca and county oversight? Would you support restricting future residential development or rezoning near the facility until the area achieves attainment status?

We felt compelled to issue a resolution of support for our residents in terms of their safety, um, in the face of the type of, of activities that Ice was conducting.

— Gary Hansen [00:33:40,240]
What role do you believe the City of Eagan should play when Ice conducts enforcement activities in the city?

I think it's really important that the city of Eagan needs to take a little bit more active role. Again, I don't want to pit ourselves against the ice.

— Jason Narverud [00:35:05,970]
What role do you believe the City of Eagan should play when Ice conducts enforcement activities in the city?

Public safety depends on trust and, um, residents should feel safe reporting crimes. And when it comes to seeking help, um, local government has a responsibility, um, that are distinct from federal immigration enforcement.

— Scott Armitage [00:36:13,910]
What role do you believe the City of Eagan should play when Ice conducts enforcement activities in the city?

Our police department does not, has never and will not ask about somebody's immigration status when responding to a call. everybody needs to feel comfortable reaching out and calling 911 and asking for help and knowing that help is on the way and that immigration status isn't going to be a part of the interaction with local police.

— Paul Bakken [00:37:50,260]
What role do you believe the City of Eagan should play when Ice conducts enforcement activities in the city?

It's going to give us the time we need in order to study the issues to update our ordinances in order to again protect the interests and the health and safety of of the public. Uh, some of those things are water usage, noise, light pollution, other types of negative externalities that aren't compatible with existing established surrounding areas.

— Paul Bakken [00:39:53,490]
Eagan was the first city in Minnesota to pass a moratorium on new data center development. As a council member, do you support the moratorium as the right way to study impacts like electricity demand and water use before more data centers are built? When the moratorium expires, what specific standards would standards would you want in place before Eagan allows new data center projects to move forward?

Some of the issues obviously are the forever chemicals, the noises, um, the limited, um, employment, um, the air pollution and things like this, but there are opportunities to limit water use and electricity when data centers are built. And the city of Eagan has that opportunity to do that. Um, I am at this moment anti data centers because it is such a concern for our community.

— Scott Armitage [00:41:27,710]
Eagan was the first city in Minnesota to pass a moratorium on new data center development. As a council member, do you support the moratorium as the right way to study impacts like electricity demand and water use before more data centers are built? When the moratorium expires, what specific standards would standards would you want in place before Eagan allows new data center projects to move forward?

There is a need, yes, for data centers, we have to acknowledge that, but they have to be properly located. Um, and I don't know that in the city of Eagan, uh, which is almost fully developed, we really have any places where additional data centers could be developed.

— Gary Hansen [00:43:18,500]
Eagan was the first city in Minnesota to pass a moratorium on new data center development. As a council member, do you support the moratorium as the right way to study impacts like electricity demand and water use before more data centers are built? When the moratorium expires, what specific standards would standards would you want in place before Eagan allows new data center projects to move forward?

One of the things that I do in my job is really read the details. And one of the things that I think data centers are really getting away with is what happens if they decide to walk away, what happens if there's a leak? What happens if they want to decommission a certain way, or they want to just go ahead and not decommissioned and there's a leak.

— Jason Narverud [00:44:26,080]
Eagan was the first city in Minnesota to pass a moratorium on new data center development. As a council member, do you support the moratorium as the right way to study impacts like electricity demand and water use before more data centers are built? When the moratorium expires, what specific standards would standards would you want in place before Eagan allows new data center projects to move forward?

I think for me, it's really, I think representation. I think Eagan is not the same city that it was ten, 20 years ago. And I want to make sure the fact that there's representation in the city

— Jason Narverud [00:45:26,880]
What is the most important issue facing Eagan that's not receiving enough attention?

We have a couple of major initiatives in Eagan. And one of those is race equity and inclusion. And the other is sustainability.

— Gary Hansen [00:46:57,490]
What is the most important issue facing Eagan that's not receiving enough attention?

In previous years and I suspect coming up again this year, there are efforts afoot at the state legislature to remove some land use planning authority from cities. I don't think that's a good idea, and I don't think enough people are paying attention to just how much impact that would have on our community.

— Paul Bakken [00:48:21,500]
What is the most important issue facing Eagan that's not receiving enough attention?

It's clear to me by a lot of the questions there is, um, seems to be a lack of communication. Um, there are a lot of things I didn't know about her and I didn't understand, um, that came up and, and I think that's a, that's a big issue for me, um, is reaching all the residents and letting them know what is going on.

— Scott Armitage [00:50:03,880]
What is the most important issue facing Eagan that's not receiving enough attention?

Ordinances & Resolutions (4)

resolution of supportResolution

Issued by Eagan City Council to support residents' safety during ICE activities

state implementation planPlan

A new plan pending for the Gopher Resources lead smelter area following an MPCA investigation

moratorium on new data center developmentOrdinance

Passed by Eagan City Council to study impacts before allowing more data centers

ordinancesOrdinance

To be updated to address impacts of data centers like water usage, noise, and light pollution

View Source
Eagan City Council - Eagan Recorder