Tax Expenditure Review Commission 11/18/26
Housing Contribution Credit Evaluation
2026 Tax Expenditure Budget Presentation
Initial Review of Film Production Credit Objective
Initial Review of Television Commercials Sales Tax Exemption Objective
Initial Review of Textbooks and Personal Computers Sales Tax Exemption Objective
Initial Review of Social Security Income Tax Subtraction Objective
Initial Review of National Guard and Reserve Pay Income Tax Subtraction Objective
Full Document Analysis
Votes (6)
Recommendation for Housing Contribution Tax Credit Bundle (State Housing Tax Credit)
Moved by Co-chair Davids [00:21:05]
LBO Director Christian Larson presented evaluation summaries for the individual income, corporate franchise, and insurance premium tax components. Member feedback showed a split between continuing and modifying the credits. Discussion centered on the need for more information, better allocation between rental and homeownership, and the credit's relatively short time in place. Commissioner Marquart sought clarification on whether modification comments would be included in the final report, which was confirmed by LBO Director Larson.
Film Production Credit Objective Approval
Moved by Co-chair Davids [00:50:47]
LBO analyst Carl Palm presented an updated objective for the film production credit, focusing on increasing production and related economic activities. Councilor Gomez questioned the lack of baseline analysis to measure 'increase' and cautioned against relying solely on industry-driven data, citing concerns about transferable credits and uncapped limits seen in other states and industries.
Television Commercial Sales Tax Exemption Objective Approval
Moved by Co-chair Davids [00:55:04]
LBO analyst Carl Palm introduced the proposed objective to enhance Minnesota's competitiveness and encourage TV commercial promotion. Chair Igbaje raised questions about the interaction of digital and television commercials and the effectiveness of current measures. Councilor Gomez emphasized the importance of measurable language in objective statements, comparing the 'enhancing competitiveness' phrasing to the more direct 'increase' used for the film production credit.
Textbooks and Personal Computers for School Use Exemption Objective Approval
Moved by Co-chair Davids [01:02:40]
LBO analyst Joel Enders presented the objective for these bundled exemptions: to further the accessibility and public purpose of education. Chair Igbaje requested that future evaluations provide breakdowns of student types, awareness levels of the exemption, and ensure coverage of all educational institutions, including trade schools.
Social Security Income Tax Subtraction Objective Approval
Moved by Co-chair Davids [01:08:08]
LBO analyst Joel Enders presented the proposed objective to reduce the tax burden for Social Security recipients affected by inflation and cost of living increases. Chair Igbaje expressed strong interest in the upcoming full review, particularly the comparative analysis with how other states treat Social Security income.
National Guard and Reserve Pay Income Tax Subtraction Objective Approval
Moved by Co-chair Davids [01:11:47]
LBO analyst Joel Enders presented the objective for the National Guard and Reserve Pay Income Tax Subtraction, which aims to increase and maintain enrollment by decreasing service members' state tax burdens. No further discussion or questions were raised by the commission members after the presentation.
Notable Quotes (11)
Um, you know, it seems like at least from the members of the commission, there is clearly a sense that there either needs to be more information or a better balance or a better um mix of kind of how the expenditure has been used across the state, especially when it comes to the division between rental and home ownership.
Chair Igbaje, Ms. Commissioner Marcquart, uh we do make comments on what the discussion was around the tax expenditure and then what the I will include the summary evaluation package that we included. So you'll see the the direct member comments as well as a summary of the discussion around it in the committee hearing or commission hearing.
The objective of the film production credit is to increase film, television, and digital media production in Minnesota to stimulate workforce development and increase ancillary economic activity.
I mean I guess just to go back to the data I I want to say that you know having seen a number of uh of especially these credits that are that you can easily transfer that basically you know get granted to one um taxpayer and then sold at a slightly at like a lower rate to a taxpayer that has Minnesota liability. Um, that uh you know there are there are um it's hard to find reliable information is what I'll say about things like these like the snow bait uh because there are entire industries basically of people who are there to to advocate for them.
The proposed objective of the television commercials exemption is to enhance Minnesota's competitiveness in the television production industry and to encourage the promotion of TV commercials in Minnesota.
I'll just you know for if we're looking at trying to evaluate things, I think the more that we can uh come up with purpose statements that lead us to measures that we can measure or you know things we can measure the better, but thank you.
The objective of the textbooks and personal computers for school use exemptions is to further the accessibility and public purpose of education by exempting teaching aids and equipment that are required for a course or general study.
I guess one additional potential metric, I mean, I know you guys already do this, but it would be really good to see the breakdown of like which types of students are taking this and how many students know about it. Um, particularly the expanded versions as well too.
The objective of the social security income subtraction is to reduce the tax burden of social security recipients with incomes that are sensitive to inflation and cost of living increases.
Well I'll say that this is probably a review a lot of us are looking forward to seeing. So um the initial review looks like it should be measuring what we want it to. So thank you for that.
The objective of the National Guard and Reserve pay subtraction is to increase and maintain enrollment in the Minnesota National Guard and Reserves by decreasing service members state tax burdens.
Ordinances & Resolutions (8)
Statute governing tax expenditure evaluations and commission duties.
Specific subdivision referenced for LBO procedures.
Specific subdivision referenced for duties in motion.
Annual report that will include commission recommendations.
Document presented by LBO summarizing member feedback on tax expenditures.
The newly released report from the Department of Revenue, presented by Eric Wallat.
A bill from the 2005 regular session related to National Guard incentive programs.
Bill in which the personal computer exemption was offered as an amendment.
Raw materialstranscript
transcript