Bloomington City Council — Transcript

Monday, July 20, 2026

Nine Mile Creek Restoration Project: Oak Savannah Conversion and Community Engagement

Property Development and Permit Issues: 8350 Amston Ridge Drive / Olivia Lot Split

Smith Park Shared Use Agreement and City Fixtures

Votes (1)

Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

No action taken on public comment items; discussion deferred to August 3rd meeting. Meeting adjourned prematurely due to rising tension.

Dissent: Multiple residents voiced strong opposition to the Nine Mile Creek oak savannah conversion plan and alleged lack of transparency. Two residents expressed significant dissent regarding property development and permit issues on Amston Ridge Drive/Olivia. One resident expressed dissent regarding the city's handling of the Smith Park shared use agreement.

The public comment period featured diverse concerns from residents. The dominant issue was the Nine Mile Creek restoration, with multiple speakers passionately arguing against the proposed conversion of mature woodlands to an oak savannah, citing loss of shade, noise buffering, psychological benefits, and perceived lack of genuine public engagement. Other concerns included unpermitted property development work and structural issues on Amston Ridge Drive, as well as the city's handling of a shared use agreement for Smith Park and associated fixtures. Speakers frequently called for a pause in projects, increased transparency, and reconsideration of current plans to better align with resident preferences.

Notable Quotes (6)

My concern is not with the restoration itself, but with the decision to convert approximately 40 acres of mature woodland into an oak savannah. The city is choosing to replace diverse woodland with oak savannah. But that is not the only choice they have.

Connie Anderson [0:46]
Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

I've been told that it takes between 20 and 50 years to get an ecosystem completely done for a a savannah. I don't know. I'm not an expert, but that's just what I've read. Now, I don't have that much time. A lot of us don't have that much time.

Mark Mercer [5:01]
Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

You as the staff and mayor have the deciding vote on whether or not to accept the planning commission's recommendation. I would recommend that you either go investigate it further or just say no. This is not right.

Mark Hansen [7:44]
Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

Without fire to remove the enormous nitrogen levels in our soil from more than a century of suppression and pollution, the conveyor belt of ecological succession is sliding into reverse. From plowing oak savannah to farmland, importing invasive Kentucky bluegrass for every yard, forced into 340 miles of car dependency, dumping a zip code of poisons into the geoengineered creek while Bachman's profited off of Buckthornne until 2001. We never left the era of colonialism.

Matthew Howlet [13:30]
Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

We were not told that a change was underway to transform our unique wooded area into a hot, sunny oak savannah and prairie. And now with the 40 acres that the city had recently been showing as Oak Savannah has increased to 58 acres in the bid documents without community input or knowledge.

Erica McMullen [18:25]
Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

I would disagree with you. I... the plan all along was for restoration. And restoration does not mean just kind of doing little nibbling around the edges. It means restoring to what it once it once was. And I think we were we were pretty straightforward with all of that.

Mayor [25:00]
Public Comment Period on City Projects and Policy Decisions

Ordinances & Resolutions (6)

RFP (Request for Proposal)Plan

Document for contractors outlining the Nine Mile Creek restoration project, showing changes from community engagement plans.

Building permitPermit

Permit for work on 8350 Amston Ridge Drive that was pulled and cancelled; issues raised about unpermitted work.

Memorandum from planning staffOther

Document related to the Olive Isle addition, providing property details mentioned by Mark Hansen.

Joint use agreement / Shared agreementOther

Agreement concerning the use of Smith Park football/soccer field and city fixtures on 8201 Park property.

Ballot questionOther

Referendum question for $20 million in improvements and restorations, which residents believe did not imply oak savannah conversion.

88-page RFP bid documentsOther

Detailed contractor documents for the Nine Mile Creek project, where residents discovered changes in scope.

View Source
Bloomington City Council - Bloomington Recorder