Crystal City Council — Transcript

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Conditional Use Permit and Variances for Accessory Structure (5700 Vagabond Lane)

Conditional Use Permit for Indoor Golf Facility (14385 23rd Avenue North)

2050 Comprehensive Plan Process Update

Votes (2)

Conditional Use Permit and Variances to allow construction of a 9600 square foot detached accessory structure, including covered sports court at 5700 Vagabond Lane

7-0 Approved

Dissent: While the final vote was unanimous, Commissioner Willis, Commissioner Fowler, and Commissioner Anderson voted against an amendment to restrict amplified sound, indicating a nuanced view on the level of regulation for private recreational uses.

Moved by Commissioner Willis [01:27:24,600] · Seconded by Commissioner Hanson [01:28:00,500]

The Planning Commission considered a CUP and three variances for a large detached accessory structure. Staff presented the proposal, noting it was for private recreational use and recommended approval with conditions regarding lighting, noise, and non-commercial activity. The applicant emphasized the property's unique size and topography, justifying the variances, and agreed to the proposed conditions. Public comments were mixed; some neighbors expressed concerns about the development's character, potential noise, parking, and property values, while others supported it for promoting recreation and community. Commissioners discussed specific conditions around parking and sound amplification, leading to amendments to the original motion.

Conditional use permit to allow indoor sports, fitness, commercial recreation use for a golf facility at 14385 23rd Avenue North

7-0 Approved

Dissent: None

Moved by Commissioner Willis [01:46:00,970] · Seconded by Commissioner Hanson [01:46:00,970]

Jeff Samson, Associate Planner, presented the staff report for a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for a youth golf training facility. The facility would include five golf simulators, lounge space, a putting green, and a pro shop within a 3993 sq ft area of an existing building. Operations were specified as pre-arranged rental appointments, focusing on youth golfers, with specific hours and limited staff/capacity. Staff confirmed the proposed parking would meet requirements. The applicant's representative, Paul Carr, offered to answer questions. No members of the public spoke during the public hearing. Commissioners did not have further questions or discussion.

Notable Quotes (5)

if the applicants would wish to change that, there would have to be a zoning ordinance text amendment that would be brought before the Planning Commission and ultimately decided by city Council if that were ever going to change.

— Kip Berglund, Senior Planner [00:23:09,970]
Conditional Use Permit and Variances to allow construction of a 9600 square foot detached accessory structure, including covered sports court at 5700 Vagabond Lane

It's a single family residential use. This is simply a permissible accessory. Recreational use to that.

— Craig Hardy, Attorney Larkin Hoffman [00:26:17,400]
Conditional Use Permit and Variances to allow construction of a 9600 square foot detached accessory structure, including covered sports court at 5700 Vagabond Lane

I don't see that this provides any good to the community. It only perhaps provides some good to the person that owns the property.

— Steven Fiscal, Resident [00:52:45,400]
Conditional Use Permit and Variances to allow construction of a 9600 square foot detached accessory structure, including covered sports court at 5700 Vagabond Lane

I believe things like this, they're great for our community. Um, they encourage play, they encourage recreation, they encourage communities to get together and gather.

— Troy Osborne, Resident [00:56:34,200]
Conditional Use Permit and Variances to allow construction of a 9600 square foot detached accessory structure, including covered sports court at 5700 Vagabond Lane

I think vagabond is more of a concern because our driveway is very short. I do not have a long driveway. That's the natural driveway to the front of our house. So if we already have two of our own vehicles in our driveway, we probably have room for one more vehicle. And so then the natural spot would be to park on our cul de sac, which is part of vagabond.

— Jess Maduro, Property Owner [01:27:07,530]
Conditional Use Permit and Variances to allow construction of a 9600 square foot detached accessory structure, including covered sports court at 5700 Vagabond Lane

Ordinances & Resolutions (13)

Conditional Use Permit (CUP)Permit

Required for a detached accessory structure greater than 700 sq ft in the FRD district, and for indoor sports fitness commercial recreation use in the I2 district.

VariancesOther

Requested for a second accessory structure > 200 sq ft, an accessory structure larger than the home, and an accessory structure exceeding the height of the home at 5700 Vagabond Lane.

Comprehensive PlanPlan

Overall guiding document for city development and land use.

Draft ResolutionResolution

Document outlining proposed conditions for the Conditional Use Permit for 5700 Vagabond Lane.

Zoning OrdinanceOrdinance

City code governing land use and property development, referenced for accessory structures and home occupations.

Zoning Ordinance Text AmendmentOrdinance

Process required to change city code, potentially for allowing commercial operations in accessory structures.

Wetland DelineationOther

Report submitted for review, required to establish wetland boundaries for construction setback compliance.

Watershed Impact ReportReport

Mentioned as still in process, related to the wetland area on 5700 Vagabond Lane.

Exterior Lighting StandardsOther

City standards that proposed lighting for the sport court must comply with.

Noise OrdinanceOrdinance

City ordinance setting standards for noise levels, applicable to all receiving land uses.

2050 Comprehensive PlanPlan

The city's long-range plan currently under development, with an update presented.

Existing Conditions ReportReport

An 88-page document providing a data-intensive snapshot of Plymouth's current demographics, economy, and land use as part of the 2050 Comprehensive Plan.

Affordable Housing Allocation requirementsOther

Requirements from the Met Council for adding 1035 new affordable housing units by 2050.

View Source
Crystal City Council - Crystal Recorder