Eden Prairie — Transcript

Tuesday, June 9, 2026Analysis complete

Areas of Interest

  • Controversy over density and lot size waivers for the Marshall Gardens development, balancing developer needs with neighborhood concerns.
  • Debate on whether the proposed development negatively impacts property values and neighborhood character, with staff presenting data to counter concerns.
  • The role of undevelopable land (steep slopes, bluffs) in the project's land dedication and waiver requests.
  • Developer's strategy to address neighborhood concerns about privacy and the 'wall effect' through setbacks, landscaping, and lot configuration.
  • Examination of the comprehensive plan amendment process and how land use guidance evolves for properties.
  • Analysis of the affordability aspect of the housing products offered, particularly the villa-style homes, and their impact on the local market.
  • The conflict between dedicating land for open space preservation and the potential for development on flatter areas south of the creek.

9 Topics in This Document

Pledge of Allegiance

Approval of Agenda

Approval of Minutes

Public Hearing: Marshall Gardens Development

Staff Report

Applicant/Developer Presentation

Public Testimony

Commission Discussion/Deliberation

Vote on Marshall Gardens Development

Full Extraction
  • Controversy over density and lot size waivers for the Marshall Gardens development, balancing developer needs with neighborhood concerns.
  • Debate on whether the proposed development negatively impacts property values and neighborhood character, with staff presenting data to counter concerns.
  • The role of undevelopable land (steep slopes, bluffs) in the project's land dedication and waiver requests.
  • Developer's strategy to address neighborhood concerns about privacy and the 'wall effect' through setbacks, landscaping, and lot configuration.
  • Examination of the comprehensive plan amendment process and how land use guidance evolves for properties.
  • Analysis of the affordability aspect of the housing products offered, particularly the villa-style homes, and their impact on the local market.
  • The conflict between dedicating land for open space preservation and the potential for development on flatter areas south of the creek.

Generally in these situations, the city looks to acquire properties like this. Finding that the ability to maintain and manage these type of features is to the community's long-term benefit. And if you look at a city map, you'll see a lot of these type of properties are owned by the city. Rarely is a situation where the city pays for them. We look for the developer to give those to us to protect that kind of character that we need prairie appreciate so much.

JeremyLand Dedication and Open SpaceAddressing the comment about donated land being undevelopable and the city's approach to acquiring open space.

So, it's important from a commission standpoint that you're not evaluating this project based on what you liked about the other project, but what is in front of you today because everything reverted back to the original rural zoning and kind of the configuration that the property is now.

JeremyProject History and Current EvaluationProviding background on the previous Marshall Gardens project and reminding the commission to focus on the current proposal.

However, we haven't seen the evidence. The city of Scissor tells me there's really no evidence to support a new development and infill type situation negatively impacting property values.

JeremyProperty Values and Development ImpactResponding to neighborhood concerns about potential negative impacts on property values.

So, there will be homes visible where there isn't any now. However, what they're asking for isn't out of character for a 9 R1 9.5 zoning district.

JeremyDevelopment Density and VisibilityAddressing concerns about the 'wall effect' and increased visibility between existing and new homes.

The developer though is using some of their their tree replacement requirements and putting trees along the north property line here and then also along the west property line.

JeremyLandscaping and ScreeningExplaining landscaping efforts by the developer to mitigate visual impact.

So, it may have been accidental, but it it appears to me as though we're offering those neighbors more visibility between homes, having more lots with standard sideyard setbacks than fewer lots with standard sideyard setbacks. Accum we're accumulating more open space by having more lots.

FarLot Width Waivers and VisibilityQuestioning the impact of lot width waivers on visibility and the amount of 'negative space' between homes.

So, we're excited about it. I think that we had a great neighborhood meeting too with the neighbors and I am meeting with them in a week or so on a Sunday afternoon to talk about tree removal and screening and so forth and so on. So I've dealt with issues like this in the past and we will definitely address this in this particular case.

Steve SchweersDeveloper Engagement and Project IntroductionIntroducing the project and highlighting proactive engagement with neighbors.

So to make lots bigger and addressing Ed's comments, you know, just to be bigger, we did stable path, you know, we had certain setbacks and stuff and I don't think it looked congested by any means, but it was affordable and they sold quickly.

Steve SchweersAffordability and Lot SizeResponding to a commissioner's comments about lot size and explaining the approach to affordability.

As far as the engineering portion of the project, sanitary sewer is pretty straightforward. There's access on Dell Road and on Canopy. water the same bell road and canopy. So, it's served well.

Dan SchmidtUtilities and InfrastructureDescribing the project's utility infrastructure.

Comparing this project to the Marshall Gardens project, they had 115 total units. We're at 50 total units, 22 of which are we're calling the single family. And they're the bigger, wider lots. And the 28 villas, we've been calling them villas, but they're technically single family, I believe, too. But they're 55 feet wide.

Dan SchmidtProject Density ComparisonComparing the current project's density and unit count to the previous Marshall Gardens project.

So, we've asked for a waiver to go to 9% on the garages. Our target, these are not age restricted, but our target market for the villas are empty nesters, or people that are fully retired or even older, 70s, 80s. That's who we're selling.

Paul RylandGarage Waivers and Target MarketDiscussing garage size waiver and the target demographic for the villa homes.

So, even though the lots may be narrow, they are actually quite deep and we're it gives us a lot of flexibility, backyards and things like that.

Paul RylandLot Dimensions and FlexibilityExplaining the lot depth in relation to the requested lot width waivers.

So, our rams will have a basement, but that is a floor plan and a design that a lot of clients are looking for these days because a lot of them are those young empty nesters and maybe they've been in their existing home for quite a period of time and they're looking for something that allows either main level living, lower maintenance, newer construction, you know, modern mechanicals and all of those things.

David RemickSingle-Family Home Product FeaturesDescribing the single-family home product, focusing on features attractive to empty nesters and those seeking lower maintenance.

My wife and I moved here from Minnotonka to Eden Prairie about six, seven years ago. We love the community. We picked the right place.

Richard CopyCommunity AffiliationIntroducing himself during public testimony, expressing satisfaction with living in Eden Prairie.