Edina City Council — Transcript

Tuesday, January 6, 2026

Conditional Local Gun Regulating Ordinance

Votes (1)

Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

No action taken; further consideration scheduled for January 20, 2026 meeting.

The council held a public hearing on a proposed ordinance that would regulate certain types of firearms (e.g., semi-automatic weapons, large capacity magazines, binary triggers) within Edina. City Attorney Dave Kendall explained that the ordinance is currently preempted by state law (MN Statute 471.633) but is drafted to become effective only if state preemption is lifted and the council passes a subsequent resolution. Supporters, including many parents, students, teachers, and healthcare professionals, shared emotional testimonies about the devastating impact of gun violence, particularly on children, citing events like the Annunciation Church shooting. They argued for the council to take action to prevent further tragedies, emphasizing that the ordinance targets 'weapons of war' and promotes community safety. Opponents raised concerns about state preemption, potential constitutional challenges (Second Amendment), the criminalization of law-abiding citizens, and the ordinance's effectiveness, suggesting that focus should be on mental health issues and enforcement of existing laws. They advocated for state or federal action instead of local measures.

Notable Quotes (12)

Our city attorney has responded to that request, creating a proposed form of ordinance that is contingent in its implementation upon our council passing a resolution should the legislature ever choose to overturn the ban on cities regulating the sale of certain types of firearms and ammunition.

Mayor Hublin [3:50]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

It does say the legislature preempts all authority of cities to regulate firearms, ammunition, and their components to the complete exclusion of any ordinance uh passed by that city. There's one exception to that, and that is regulation of discharge of firearms within the city.

Mr. Kendall, City Attorney [5:10]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

As the grandmother who held this baby Fletcher Merkel, who lost his life at the enunciation shooting, I can only talk to him now in my dreams. I'm asking for people to reflect on what cultural and social impedance we can set up. What would help to limit the gun violence?

Carol Flint Cleby [15:15]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

gun control laws have not reduced crime in other cities. You have to take on you have to look at the experience of other cities. There are many studies published on this topic. Cities, if you look at cities with very strict gun laws like Chicago and New York and others, they still have very high rates of violent crime.

Dave Wright [18:20]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

Mass shootings involving assault weapons result in six times as many people shot and twice as many people killed as compared to incidents involving other firearms. When large capacity magazines are used, the number of people killed increases by more than 60%. The number wounded by more than 100%.

Aaron Zamoff [32:55]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

The right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Those words apparently don't mean much... Why would you try to restrict and interfere with law-abiding citizens that had nothing to do with this act of evil?

Dan Nye [35:10]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

Since 2020, gunshot wounds have been the leading cause of death among kids ages 1 to 17 in the United States. Not cancer, not car crashes, not peanut allergies, gunshot wounds.

Dr. Trish Velusk, Pediatric Trauma Surgeon [1:16:35]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

This did not have to happen. I'm not referring simply to violence that has and always will be with us but rather the sheer even grotesque immensity of the violence. Of the 119 rounds of gunfire discharged, 116 were fired in a minute from illegally purchased semiotic automatic weapon.

Pastor David Los [1:26:50]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

America is embarrassingly and inexcusably alone with regard to the frequency and the quantum of gun violence. This is a uniquely American problem and it's because in America it is easier to it is easier to legally own a weapon of war than it is to drive a car.

Julie Green, State Representative [1:50:50]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

We can't do anything locally until the state does it. They have the authority over our municipality and every m municipality in the state. We have to put our efforts toward state level and from there go on to national to the federal level.

Janie Weston [2:24:50]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

right or wrong, under current state and federal law, you as Edina City Council members have no legal ability or authority to pass gun regulations. I would strongly encourage you to pass a proclamation that supports all of the regulations outlined in the proposed ordinance. It will accomplish the same goal.

Kirk Adalan [2:35:50]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

We don't have any greater incidence of mental health problems than any other country in the world, but we're there's a lot more people getting killed here with military-style assault weapons than anywhere in the world. So, to say that guns aren't a factor here is denying the reality of what is indeed going on.

Mayor Hublin [2:39:00]
Public Hearing on Potential Conditional Gun Ordinance

Ordinances & Resolutions (8)

Minnesota Statute 471.633Other

State statute that preempts local authority to regulate firearms and ammunition.

Proposed Edina OrdinanceOrdinance

A draft conditional gun regulating ordinance for the city of Edina, contingent on state law changes.

St. Paul ordinanceOrdinance

A similar conditional gun ordinance enacted by the City of St. Paul, used as a model for Edina's draft.

U.S. Constitution, Second AmendmentOther

Constitutional right to bear arms, frequently cited by opponents of gun regulation.

Heller decisionOther

U.S. Supreme Court case recognizing an individual right to bear arms, with limitations referenced.

Briefing memoOther

A document submitted by Dave Wright outlining arguments against the proposed ordinance.

Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA)Other

A medical publication cited for its work on firearm violence as a public health problem.

Extreme Risk Protection Order (ERPO)Other

Mentioned in context of a Parkland survivor whose ERPO lapsed, leading to a gun purchase and suicide.

View Source
Edina City Council - Edina Recorder