RecordingTranscript availableAnalysis ready58:07

Edina City Council Meeting / Sept. 3, 2024

Edina City CouncilSunday, March 16, 2025
Watch on original source

Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for Macy's Site Development

Asian-American Church Proposal for Art Center

E-Bike Safety and Regulation

Railroad Crossing Safety Improvements

Excel Energy Grid Reliability

Municipal Brush Disposal Service

France Avenue Underpass Project

Met Council Population Estimates

Traffic Safety and Fatalities

Pedestrian Safety at 50th Street and Eden Avenue Roundabout

Drug Activity at 4040 West 70th Street

Federal Funding Opportunities and Regional Advocacy

Full Document Analysis

Votes (10)

Resolution 2024-56: Grant Application for Railroad Crossing Elimination Program

5-0 Approved (Unanimous)

Dissent: None

Moved by Council Member Jackson [Timestamp] · Seconded by Council Member Pierce [Timestamp]

Council Member Jackson requested clarification on timeline for federal grant application and expected outcomes. Director Milner explained that the application is due in late September/early October with results expected by year-end, followed by a one-year safety review of seven at-grade crossings. The focus is on safety improvements (crossing arms, signage, lights) rather than elimination, as the crossings serve low-volume, low-speed rail traffic.

Resolution 2024-59: Acceptance of Donations

5-0 Approved (Unanimous - Super Majority Required)

Dissent: None

Moved by Council Member Jackson [Timestamp] · Seconded by Council Member U [Timestamp]

Mayor Huband announced acceptance of a $3,200 memorial bench donation from Jackie Holowinski of Apple Valley to be installed at Centennial Lakes Park. The donation will be posted on the city website as a tribute to a loved one.

E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

No formal vote; Council directed staff to research helmet ordinances and pursue expedited action while Transportation Commission studies broader best practices

Dissent: None; consensus on need for action

Moved by None - Discussion Item · Seconded by None - Discussion Item

Multiple residents raised safety concerns about e-bikes operating at excessive speeds on sidewalks and bike trails, with some riders under the legal age of 15. City Attorney Dave and Police Chief discussed current state law, which classifies e-bikes similarly to bicycles. Key points: (1) State law requires riders to be 15+ years old; (2) Sidewalk speed limit is 10 mph under existing ordinance; (3) Helmet requirements for those under 18 are possible and have been adopted by other Twin Cities cities; (4) E-bikes must obey same traffic laws as bicycles; (5) Speed regulation on city bike trails is possible; (6) Three Rivers Park District may regulate speeds on their trails. Council expressed interest in expedited action on helmet requirements and immediate awareness campaigns while Transportation Commission studies best practices.

Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for Macy's Site - Public Comment and Manager Response

No vote; Matter remains under negotiation with commitment to present full details to council

Dissent: Resident Ziker expressed strong concerns about transparency and accuracy of prior responses

Moved by None - Public Comment and Manager Response · Seconded by None - Public Comment and Manager Response

Resident Ralph Ziker raised concerns about transparency in HRA presentations regarding a proposed $23 million TIF for the Macy's site on France Avenue. Ziker questioned: (1) why interest cost estimates were not shared with residents; (2) whether the $23 million TIF closes the financing gap; and (3) the developer's required rate of return. He cited discrepancies between Manager Neil's public responses and an email to Council Member Risser. Manager Neil responded that the city uses a pay-as-you-go TIF model where taxes are only returned to developers if they complete agreed projects and pay taxes, protecting taxpayers. He stated that all fiscal details, including interest costs, will be presented to council before approval is requested, and that the city will not approve agreements with 'major fiscal holes.'

Asian-American Church Proposal for Art Center

No vote; Director Veter to review proposal materials; matter deferred pending future master planning and county negotiations

Dissent: None

Moved by None - Public Comment and Information · Seconded by None - Public Comment and Information

Eric Ong presented a proposal from Minnetonka Chinese Christian Church (MNCC) to purchase the art center and transform it into a place of worship and multicultural hub. The proposal emphasizes community engagement, cultural exchange, and educational programming. MNCC has 26 years of community involvement and collected 137 resident signatures of support. Director Veter clarified that the art center is currently in use for programming and will not be available for alternative use until at least 2027. The city is exploring a potential tenant agreement with Hennepin County for a new library space. Any future use of the art center site would require master planning, land use review, and consideration of its location within Rosland Park. Mayor Huband acknowledged the church's interest and suggested continued conversation about potential future opportunities.

Excel Energy Grid Reliability and Public Utilities Commission Filing

No formal vote; City Manager directed to publicize PUC contact information and file formal city comments

Dissent: None

Moved by None - Information and Direction · Seconded by None - Information and Direction

Manager Neil reported on recent power outages and directed residents to file complaints with the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC) Consumer Affairs office. The filing period closes September 12th. Supervisor Ann Tom is the contact person. The city plans to publicize contact information and file formal comments on behalf of the city regarding Excel Energy's performance and grid resilience. Council Member Rer expressed concern about the trend of increasing traffic fatalities and the need for Excel Energy to improve grid resilience in the context of changing climate patterns.

Municipal Brush Disposal Service Exploration

No formal vote; Council directed staff to explore feasibility of resuming brush disposal service at alternative locations

Dissent: None

Moved by None - Discussion Item · Seconded by None - Discussion Item

Council Member Agnu requested exploration of resuming city-operated brush disposal services, noting that many other cities offer this service and that residents have expressed interest following recent storms. Director Veter indicated that the previous brush disposal site had logistical issues and would require identifying alternative locations and equipment to resume the program. Council Member Huband expressed support, noting that Minneapolis offers similar leaf pickup services and that this is a valued community service.

France Avenue Underpass Project - Formal Council Discussion

No formal vote; Council directed staff to prepare a resolution for formal discussion of France Avenue underpass project next steps

Dissent: None

Moved by None - Request for Staff Action · Seconded by None - Request for Staff Action

Council Member Agnu requested that staff prepare a resolution to formally discuss next steps for a potential underpass on France Avenue between the Macy's site (7235 France) and adjacent properties. She noted that the HRA received an update on the underpass possibility and emphasized the need to coordinate timing with other development projects to avoid wasted investment and ensure project alignment.

Met Council Population Estimates - Comment Period

No formal vote; Mayor indicated city will provide information on comment process

Dissent: None

Moved by None - Request for Information · Seconded by None - Request for Information

Council Member Jackson requested information on the city's process to formally comment on Met Council's 2050 population estimates during the current comment period. She indicated that the estimates are unrealistically high and that the city should submit formal comments to push for more realistic projections.

Federal Funding Opportunities and Regional Advocacy Value

No formal vote; Mayor encouraged staff to pursue EV charging infrastructure grant opportunities

Dissent: None

Moved by None - Information and Encouragement · Seconded by None - Information and Encouragement

Mayor Huband explained the value of city participation in the U.S. Conference of Mayors and regional government organizations. He noted that such involvement enabled the city to influence major federal legislation (IIJA, IRA) and access competitive grant programs. He highlighted EV charging infrastructure funding with $500 million available nationally and encouraged the city to pursue such opportunities. He also referenced items 6.8 and 6.9 on the consent agenda as examples of grants made possible through federal advocacy.

Notable Quotes (24)

I just wanted to um highlight this I'm glad that we're applying for this I we've hear a lot about the railroad crossings being unsafe and um I just wanted to ask director Milner uh sort of the timeline expected timeline I know federal grants sometimes take a while but um the application is going in with this resolution and then when do you think we'll hear back

— Council Member Jackson [Timestamp]
Resolution 2024-56: Grant Application for Railroad Crossing Elimination Program

the application's due late September early October um I think we'll hear back by the end of the year and then it's about a year study for these it's a safety review of The Seven Crossings we have in town okay and with the potential to eliminate the crossings we don't think there's a possibility not really focusing on elimination because they're all at grade crossings that would be major Bridges and major underpasses we're looking at safety improvements such as Crossing arms signage lights stuff like that

— Director Milner [Timestamp]
Resolution 2024-56: Grant Application for Railroad Crossing Elimination Program

this reporting period there was a donation from uh a lady from Apple Valley named Holo winsky and it is a memorial bench at Centennial Lakes Park a $3,200 gift and that will be posted up on the city website so thank you Jackie holowinski from Apple Valley for remembering a loved one uh in the city of Edina and putting a special bench in at Centennial Lakes

— Mayor Huband [Timestamp]
Resolution 2024-59: Acceptance of Donations

I've seen kids on sidewalks going 20 M an hour two weeks ago I had a teenager play chicken with me on my bicycle came right at me and turned at the last second I almost had to hit him to keep him from hitting me uh you might be aware it was in the newspaper city of excel Shire has a new ordinance that requires anybody under 18 who's writing an ebike to wear a helmet City VI Dino should be looking at those types of things

— Resident David Frankl [Timestamp]
E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

I you know I sent an email we saw a kid on an ebike popping a wheelie down Vernon and I don't know how old the kid was but he was popping a wheelie down Vernon in the bike lane and my wife and I said you know if that was our kid and somebody told us they saw our kid popping a wheelie on an ebike going down Vernon because of the safety issue that's inappropriate... I think we should be I I understand enforcement right I get that and legalities um and so I I think that is one lane that we need to be in but I think we also need to be talking about um is there some and I don't know if it's awareness or what

— Council Member Pierce [Timestamp]
E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

I am aware that several other cities uh in the Twin Cities area have recently either considered or enacted um helmet requirements for use of vbikes in their cities uh I don't think that's probably preempted by state law... I think it would be possible for cities to consider an ordinance requiring helmets particularly for those under 18

— City Attorney Dave [Timestamp]
E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

under State Statute it's a little murky because we have city ordinance and state statute that kind of sort of regulates uh much of what we're talking about today but uh you can operate a ebike on a shoulder of a roadway you can operate it in a bicycle lane and in a bicycle route under State Statute um you have to be 15 years or older right so if you're under that you cannot operate an ebike

— Police Chief [Timestamp]
E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

regardless of how we handle an ordinance you know research project or actually get it enacted it takes time and we're still on the back end of summer into fall and we have a really good Communications team and we already have statutory language in place and ordinance language in place we could do some marketing right away and get some information out because I think there's just a lot of people out there that are uninformed

— Manager Neil [Timestamp]
E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

I do feel like there's some immediacy to some aspects of this that we ought to be able to deal with while the Eden Transportation Commission looks at Best Practices around the country but the idea of making them wear a helmet if some of those other things I don't see why we wouldn't do something about that

— Council Member Rer [Timestamp]
E-Bike Safety and Regulation Discussion

two years ago it wasn't too early for the developer to predict an interest rate was it precise no but you can be darn sure an interest cost was calculated and shared with with investors what Mr Neil is really saying is that it's too early for residents to be fully informed too early to be told that interest on the Macy's Tiff notes will suck up another 15 to $25 million of city property tax revenue making this not a 23 million but a 4 million a $40 million gift of Tiff

— Resident Ralph Ziker [Timestamp]
Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for Macy's Site - Public Comment and Manager Response

no wonder the project meets the butt for test mayor council members when will the lack of transparency and Mr Neil's ongoing behavior of dissing residents with replies that are not replies become unacceptable finally a personal thank you to member Pierce and member Risser for asking probing thoughtful questions and voicing substantial concerns

— Resident Ralph Ziker [Timestamp]
Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for Macy's Site - Public Comment and Manager Response

we are not saying nor we would nor would we ever recommend from a staff perspective that the city just take $23 million of publicly issued bonds and hand that over to a developer that's not how it works it's never how it's worked here in a Dina we issue pay as you go notes meaning that if the developer does a project that is uh consistent with a pre-negotiated agreement with the city and they pay their taxes that's some of those taxes go back to pay that developer so if they don't do the project that qualifies under the agreement or they don't pay their taxes they don't get the money and that that protects uh the city and the taxpayers

— City Manager Neil [Timestamp]
Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for Macy's Site - Public Comment and Manager Response

yes there there is interest bearing there's an interest bearing element in this agreement uh those things are all under negotiation uh the council will see those numbers and you'll see precisely what they are uh before you know before or at or close to the time you're going to be asked to make a judgment on whether it's in the Public's interest or not uh to approve that agreement so you will not be asked to approve an agreement with major fiscal holes in it

— City Manager Neil [Timestamp]
Tax Increment Financing (TIF) for Macy's Site - Public Comment and Manager Response

transforming the art center into a vibrant Rally Point for fostter Unity and inclusivity for our d diverse Community it d as home for people from various cultural backgrounds this proposal celebrates Embrace that uh diversity and identity the new use of the space will unite individuals from diverse backgrounds fure culture exchange and mutual understanding

— Eric Ong [Timestamp]
Asian-American Church Proposal for Art Center

we are currently still utilizing the art center it is in use while it's not open to the general public we utilize it for programming um now and into the future um as you know and uh many members of the community know we are working on a uh potential agreement with hennipin County to be a tenant in their new library for our art center space but uh that is a a distant few years into the future and as you indicated uh the art center isn't just on a certain parcel it's actually within the confines of Rosland Park and um that would have a whole other set of uh requirements and research and land use uh portions of that site as well

— Director Veter [Timestamp]
Asian-American Church Proposal for Art Center

we understand your desire for a church home um and it was really uh I think really uh um wonderful that you came in to talk to your city council tonight to express an interest in in uh if there's ever an opportunity to think don't don't forget about us you know your group in terms of of if there's something that we ever do with that property it doesn't have a purely public purpose so uh thanks for coming tonight and I hope to see you uh out walking soon we can continue that conversation

— Mayor Huband [Timestamp]
Asian-American Church Proposal for Art Center

her office that she operates which is called the Consumer Affairs office uh is the correct person is the correct body within state government specifically the Pu to address uh for formally address comments about excel's performance directly to her um there is currently right now A a filing period uh that closes on September 12th uh where if people have complaints they could get them into her office and they'll be considered uh through the they'll be they'll be researched for for example but they will be considered by the Pu in that filing process

— City Manager Neil [Timestamp]
Excel Energy Grid Reliability and Public Utilities Commission Filing

I was really disappointed in the performance of Excel Energy on terms of being able to get people back up and operating with on the electrical grid you know it wasn't that many months ago where they had another episode somewhere in the state where they had to bring in several hundred people to try to make things work and um now they brought in I think 700 people from around the country and it just seems that if this if this new climate that we're operating in they better figure out a way to be more resilient

— Council Member Rer [Timestamp]
Excel Energy Grid Reliability and Public Utilities Commission Filing

we've gotten a lot of emails after the storms and I think the optic and storms and the severe weather that we had this year um and got a query about about how we used to offer City operated um brush disposal um spoke to Scott a little bit about this we don't anymore um and it seems like the site had some logistical issues and probably some things that we'd need to figure out as a city if we wanted to resume that type of service um so I just would I think it would be interesting to explore if there are other sites around the city that we could offer that

— Council Member Agnu [Timestamp]
Municipal Brush Disposal Service Exploration

I really like what member U had to say about the the pick up and pick up of the brush now talking to director veter about this we'd probably have to get some more equipment and figure out how we're going to do this but I do think it's a great service I mean it's it's just one of those wonderful things about living in a city and um and so I'd like to I'd like to think more about that you know people bring their things to the to the burm or the curb and then we figure out we're going to get it picked up just like Minneapolis does every year with leaves

— Council Member Huband [Timestamp]
Municipal Brush Disposal Service Exploration

I kind of left not really exactly sure what the next steps were I know like we were doing this like phase of the project and knowing that we're within the next short amount of time within the next couple of months going to be reviewing um that project again I'm sure we'll get another revisit from the Macy's furniture site again I I think it we need need to continue pushing it forward and I'd like to see it progress and so for this one I don't know if the right next step is to ask staff to prepare a resolution so that we as a council can like have that conversation then um and decide on next steps but I think that would be my direct ask is let's let's push it forward and let's discuss it formally as a council

— Council Member Agnu [Timestamp]
France Avenue Underpass Project - Formal Council Discussion

we we as a city council received notice from the Met Council that their population estimates um through 2050 have been published and there's a comment period right now um the population estimates are unrealistic in my mind and I wanted to um put forward that I'd like to know what the process is for us as a city to comment on these population estimates and um see if we can't um get them pushed down to something more realistic

— Council Member Jackson [Timestamp]
Met Council Population Estimates - Comment Period

without being involved beyonda or in the region or in the state or as I am with the US Conference of Mayors on the transfer ation committee us Conference of mayor has had a tremendous amount of influence on the iig ACT and also with respect to uh the IRA and so uh and and another good example of it is this Grant application we're going for with respect to railroad crossing elimination programs that is possible to apply for that Grant because of the things that cities and and City organizations like our city council we were able to influence Congress to a significant degree on some of this major leg legislation that's passed under the Biden Administration

— Mayor Huband [Timestamp]
Federal Funding Opportunities and Regional Advocacy Value

there's a half a billion dollars in this fund and this is the first go run the first two Awards in Minnesota you can see where we had two of them here one was to mot and I think one was to hopan County but you know many in many of these states it's it's some of the major cities that are getting really significant financial support for building out their EV network and so I would encourage us to be thinking about that too and that opportunity exists because of the the work that that local government does on a federal level

— Mayor Huband [Timestamp]
Federal Funding Opportunities and Regional Advocacy Value

Ordinances & Resolutions (6)

Resolution 2024-56Resolution

Support for grant application to Federal Rail Administration for railroad crossing elimination program safety review

Resolution 2024-59Resolution

Acceptance of donations on behalf of the City of Edina, including $3,200 memorial bench donation from Jackie Holowinski

Item 6.8Other

Consent agenda item removed for separate discussion regarding railroad crossing grant application

2026 Capital Improvement Plan (CIP)Plan

City budget document allocating $2.2 million for Grand View parking ramp ADA compliance

Pedestrian Crossing PolicyPolicy

City policy governing installation of pedestrian-activated flashers at intersections

City Ordinance - Sidewalk Bicycle Speed LimitOrdinance

Existing ordinance limiting bicycle speed to 10 miles per hour on sidewalks; applicability to e-bikes under review

Transcript