StoryEnvironmental Preservation and Tree OrdinancesNovember 7, 2024

Edina Council Navigates Environmental Preservation, Tree Protection Efforts

City leaders approved a unique conservation easement, debated approaches to tree ordinances, and explored green infrastructure opportunities at a recent meeting.

Published Oct 9, 2026

The Edina City Council recently tackled several agenda items centered on environmental preservation and the city’s approach to tree protection, reflecting ongoing community interest and challenges in balancing development with natural resources. Key discussions included the approval of a unique conservation easement for a vacant lot and considerations for integrating green infrastructure into upcoming projects, alongside persistent public concern over tree removals.

One significant decision involved a conservation easement for the vacant lot at 5235 Highwood Drive. Following a special assessment process, the Council voted 4-1 to approve the easement, ensuring the long-term preservation of the parcel. The initiative represents a novel approach to securing natural spaces within the city, though the process itself raised questions among some council members.

It's just really rather disconcerting that it came to us and this issue hadn't been addressed earlier on... because of the way it has come forward I really can't support this.

— Council Member Risser

Council Member Risser expressed reservations about the procedural aspects of the easement's presentation, casting the lone dissenting vote, despite the underlying goal of preservation. The approval, however, signals the city's willingness to pursue unconventional methods to protect key environmental assets.

Community Concerns Drive Tree Ordinance Discussions

The discussion around environmental preservation extended to the sensitive topic of tree ordinances and resident concerns over tree removals. The Council acknowledged continued public feedback, particularly citing an incident at 4404 West 58th Street where the removal of a healthy white oak tree sparked significant resident complaints. This event has underscored the community’s strong desire for robust tree protection measures and clearer guidelines.

Beyond individual tree removals, the Council also considered environmental stewardship within larger development projects. During discussions for Phase 2 of the 7200 France Avenue Preliminary Site Plan (PUD 16), opportunities to incorporate 'green street' principles were explored.

We have this opportunity with the sewer project... now we could look at doing those same techniques of narrowing streets, doing more curb bump outs, adding sidewalks... and consider it a Recon.

— Engineering Director Chad Milner

Engineering Director Chad Milner highlighted how planned sewer infrastructure projects could be leveraged to implement improvements such as narrower streets, curb bump-outs, and new sidewalks. These techniques, often referred to as 'Recon,' aim to enhance pedestrian safety and potentially increase green space by reducing impervious surfaces, allowing for more stormwater infiltration and tree planting.

Furthermore, community comments regarding developer maintenance were noted, with specific mention of overgrown weeds at the 70th and France (US Bank site). This feedback underscores the public’s expectation for developers to maintain sites responsibly, aligning with broader environmental aesthetics and stewardship.

The multifaceted discussions at the Council meeting reflect Edina's ongoing efforts to refine its environmental policies, from protecting specific parcels through easements to integrating sustainable design into urban development and responding to resident concerns about the city’s invaluable tree canopy. The decisions made demonstrate a continuous commitment to finding a balance that supports both growth and environmental health.

Our proprietary artificial intelligence agent analyzed publicly available documents including meeting agendas, minutes, and transcripts to write this story to help inform local residents. Feedback helps us improve, so please consider rating how we did with the thumbs up or down below.

Go deeper on this topic

Research related meeting documents and build a brief — without rewriting the story.

Full analysis

Votes (3)

Cannabis Ordinance Public Hearing

Passed Unanimously

Dissent: None for the continuation; however, Member Risser expressed concern about sidewalk smoking enforcement.

Moved by Council Member Jackson [1:15:13] · Seconded by Council Member Pierce [1:15:15]

Staff presented a plan for five retail licenses based on population. Discussion focused on 500-foot buffers. The Planning Commission recommended dropping buffers for daycares and parks, but Council Member Jackson argued for their inclusion to protect children from 'impressionable' exposure.

5235 Highwood Drive Conservation Easement

4-1 Approved

Dissent: Council Member Risser [1:45:59] voted 'Nay' due to procedural concerns.

Moved by Council Member Jackson [1:45:40] · Seconded by Council Member Pierce [1:45:45]

Debate over using municipal financing (special assessments) to help neighbors preserve private land. Member Risser objected to the process, arguing it creates non-conforming lots and bypasses standard platting procedures.

7200 France Preliminary Site Plan (Phase 2)

Discussion pending final action

Dissent: Council Member Risser questioned if the building square footage was 'similar' to Phase 1 as originally promised.

Moved by Not recorded in transcript excerpt · Seconded by Not recorded in transcript excerpt

The developer requested a reduction in first-floor ceiling height from 16 to 14 feet as the project shifted from retail to residential. Engineering staff proposed a right-out-only median on 72nd Street to prevent cut-through traffic into the residential neighborhood.

Notable Quotes (3)

Current conversation just around the buffers... can give us a false sense of security and control around this and so I definitely want to make sure... that we're focusing on the right balance.

— Council Member Pierce [48:57]
Cannabis Ordinance Public Hearing

It's just really rather disconcerting that it came to us and this issue hadn't been addressed earlier on... because of the way it has come forward I really can't support this.

— Council Member Risser [1:42:01]
5235 Highwood Drive Conservation Easement

We have this opportunity with the sewer project... now we could look at doing those same techniques of narrowing streets, doing more curb bump outs, adding sidewalks... and consider it a Recon.

— Engineering Director Chad Milner [1:57:45]
7200 France Preliminary Site Plan (Phase 2)

Ordinances & Resolutions (5)

Resolution 2024-93Resolution

Accepting various donations including $14,000 for a police K9.

Resolution 2024-86Resolution

Approving a CUP with variances for 4208 Philbrook Lane.

Resolution 2024-90Resolution

Approving the acquisition of real property at 5235 Highwood Drive for conservation.

Resolution 2024-91Resolution

Adopting the special assessment agreement for the Highwood Drive conservation project.

PUD 16Plan

The Planned Unit Development ordinance governing the 7200 France Avenue site.

Source document

Was this story helpful?

Other Topics from This Document

  • Cannabis Business Regulation and Zoning

  • Public-Private Conservation Easement

  • 7200 France Avenue Phase 2 Development

Want to know when new stories arrive?

Enter your email to receive updates.

We will not use your email for any other purpose. You can unsubscribe at any time.