November 12, 2026 Mayor Frey responds to Council vote on MPD Chief confirmation press conference
Thursday, November 12, 2026
Story
Mayor Blasts Council Vote Rejecting Police Chief Nominee Billy Peterson
The mayor says the council voted down interim Chief Billy Peterson despite a 30-year record with no sustained complaints, letters of commendation and medals of valor. He calls the vote favoritism rather than governance and says no disqualifying infractions emerged.
Possible mayoral veto of the council's denial
Mayor says a veto decision must legally be made by Wednesday or Thursday of next week; he lacks the votes for a majority and criticizes members who indicated they'd vote yes only on a second round, calling it 'games.'
Interim leadership of the Minneapolis Police Department
Peterson remains interim chief 'for the foreseeable future,' but the mayor says it is Peterson's decision whether to continue or return to being inspector of the first precinct.
Police chief search and community engagement process
Process included engagement sessions in all five precincts, an interview panel, private and public meetings with every council member, and completion within a 16-week target. External candidates withdrew, leaving no qualified external finalists.
Mayor-council relations and public safety appointments
Mayor notes a second recent public-safety loss after the office of community safety commissioner matter, and says he lost votes from traditional allies; he declines to read too much into it.
Council questioning of Peterson on racism and misconduct at MPD
Peterson faced nearly five hours of questioning, including about what he witnessed at MPD. Mayor defends his failure to recall incidents, noting he later remembered the 'racist Christmas tree' and cited ~10 discipline referrals.
Impact on MPD morale and recruitment of external candidates
Mayor says candidates have declined to apply citing 'toxicity' on the council, and warns of operational impacts and morale damage for months or years.
Areas of Interest (8)
- Ask council president and public safety committee chair to explain publicly why they voted no — mayor says neither gave reasons.
- Verify claim that council members signaled they'd vote yes only on a second confirmation vote.
- Investigate why external candidates withdrew and whether 'council toxicity' deterred applicants.
- Examine Peterson's personnel file: zero sustained complaints, medals of valor, and 10 claimed discipline referrals.
- Trace the mayor's claim that 75-80% of community feedback favored an internal candidate — obtain the engagement data.
- Follow the vacancy in the Office of Community Safety commissioner alongside the chief vacancy.
- Report on Council Member Vetaw's shift after reportedly praising Peterson days before the vote.
- Track whether Peterson remains interim chief or returns to the first precinct.
Topic analysis (7)
City Council rejection of police chief nominee Billy Peterson
The mayor says the council voted down interim Chief Billy Peterson despite a 30-year record with no sustained complaints, letters of commendation and medals of valor. He calls the vote favoritism rather than governance and says no disqualifying infractions emerged.
Possible mayoral veto of the council's denial
Mayor says a veto decision must legally be made by Wednesday or Thursday of next week; he lacks the votes for a majority and criticizes members who indicated they'd vote yes only on a second round, calling it 'games.'
- Decide on veto by Wed/Thurs next week
Interim leadership of the Minneapolis Police Department
Peterson remains interim chief 'for the foreseeable future,' but the mayor says it is Peterson's decision whether to continue or return to being inspector of the first precinct.
Police chief search and community engagement process
Process included engagement sessions in all five precincts, an interview panel, private and public meetings with every council member, and completion within a 16-week target. External candidates withdrew, leaving no qualified external finalists.
Mayor-council relations and public safety appointments
Mayor notes a second recent public-safety loss after the office of community safety commissioner matter, and says he lost votes from traditional allies; he declines to read too much into it.
Council questioning of Peterson on racism and misconduct at MPD
Peterson faced nearly five hours of questioning, including about what he witnessed at MPD. Mayor defends his failure to recall incidents, noting he later remembered the 'racist Christmas tree' and cited ~10 discipline referrals.
Impact on MPD morale and recruitment of external candidates
Mayor says candidates have declined to apply citing 'toxicity' on the council, and warns of operational impacts and morale damage for months or years.
Votes (1)
Confirmation of Billy Peterson as Minneapolis Police Chief
Notable Quotes (10)
Today it felt like favoritism and favoritism is not governance.
The underlying question is, was Billy Peterson qualified to do the job? The answer is an obvious and resounding yes.
They would say yes to him the second time, but not the first. I'm not okay with those games.
I cannot overstate the operational impact that this has on the Minneapolis Police Department for months, if not years to come.
We have had countless external candidates both for the chief of police and other positions say that they don't want to apply because they don't want to experience the toxicity on the city council.
Damn it, I forgot about the racist Christmas tree. That's what he said to me.
Not a single sustained complaint. That's not a normal thing, especially when you have a difficult job as a police officer.
He's not a politician. You know who would have answered that question really well? Brian O'Hara.
The vast majority, 75 80% of the feedback we got was to select an internal candidate.
Right now, and for the foreseeable future, it is interim chief Billy Peterson.
People (10)
Jacob FreyMayor of MinneapolisDefends nominee, discusses veto options and council relations
1 quote
Defends nominee, discusses veto options and council relations
“Today it felt like favoritism and favoritism is not governance.”
On the council vote
Billy PetersonInterim Chief, Minneapolis Police Department30-year veteran, first precinct inspector; faced 5 hours of questioning
30-year veteran, first precinct inspector; faced 5 hours of questioning
Charlie AdamsMPD commander/inspectorMayor says Council Member Vetaw told him it was not about Adams
Mayor says Council Member Vetaw told him it was not about Adams
Brian O'HaraFormer Minneapolis Police ChiefMayor cites extensive process for O'Hara's hiring and his media skill
Mayor cites extensive process for O'Hara's hiring and his media skill
Medaria ArradondoFormer Minneapolis Police ChiefMayor says Arradondo was selected without any formal process
Mayor says Arradondo was selected without any formal process
LaTrisha VetawCouncil MemberMayor says she praised Peterson days earlier and sought an internal candidate
Mayor says she praised Peterson days earlier and sought an internal candidate
Jeremiah Ellison / Council Member WarrenCouncil MemberReferenced as explaining shock Peterson couldn't recall incidents
Referenced as explaining shock Peterson couldn't recall incidents
Aisha ChughtaiCouncil MemberNamed by mayor as invited to community feedback/interview process
Named by mayor as invited to community feedback/interview process
Jamal Osman (Jameson Whiting as transcribed)Council MemberInvited to interview panel process
Invited to interview panel process
EricReporterAsked about pre-nomination vote counting strategy
Asked about pre-nomination vote counting strategy
Places Mentioned
Events & Meetings (6)
- City Council vote denying confirmation of Billy Peterson as police chief (day of press availability)
- Mayor's press availability following the council vote
- Nearly five hours of council questioning of Peterson across two days
- Veto deadline: Wednesday or Thursday of the following week
- Community engagement sessions held in all five police precincts
- 16-week chief search process