Rochester Council Postpones Quarry Permit Decision Amidst Airport Safety Concerns
Intense public and expert testimony, primarily focused on aviation safety, led the city council to delay a vote on a proposed limestone aggregate quarry, requesting further studies.
The Rochester City Council has deferred a decision on a contentious conditional use permit application for a proposed limestone aggregate quarry, following extensive testimony that underscored significant concerns regarding aviation safety and operational impacts on the nearby Rochester International Airport. After a lengthy discussion involving city staff, airport officials, the applicant, and community representatives, the council opted to postpone a vote, citing a need for more clarity and additional information.
City planning staff had initially recommended denial of the application, primarily due to potential risks to aviation. “Staff are recommending denial of this proposed application,” stated Taran Edens of the Community Development Department. “Our primary concerns are around the possibility of impairing visibility in the vicinity of the airport or otherwise endangering the landing, takeoff or maneuvering of aircraft.” These concerns were echoed and amplified by airport leadership, who focused on the specific threat posed by blasting operations.
My biggest concern is the blasting. It's 2800 ft from the end of the runway and essentially right on center line...blasting in that quarry area really effectively eliminates what's called an LV LPV approach to runway 21,” said John Reid, Executive Director of Rochester International Airport.
The applicant, MGK LLC, represented by Mark Welch of GCubed Engineering, expressed frustration with the assessment reports, particularly a recent study they characterized as biased. Welch argued that the report did not provide an independent evaluation, leading to skepticism about its findings.
This last report that came on Friday looked like a kill report... If they really truly were doing an independent study, they want to reference 1280 ft for the blasting potential. It's not an independent study. It's a kill report,” stated Mark Welch, GCubed Engineering.
Other Topics from This Document
City Administrator's Report
Mayor's Report
Conditional Use Permit for Limestone Aggregate Quarry (CD 2026008)
2027 Annual Action Plan Community Development Block Grant Allocations (G2)
Want to know when new stories arrive?
Enter your email to receive updates.
We will not use your email for any other purpose. You can unsubscribe at any time.