St. Paul City Council — Transcript
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
DSI Business Licensing Operations Audit Scope
Capstone Paper Update on Audit Committee Structure
Audit Committee Future Schedule and Leadership Transition
Votes (2)
Wilder Research Update on DSI Business Licensing Audit
Dissent: None
Moved by Chair Naker [24:14] · Seconded by Committee member Dworth [22:27] (implied consensus)
Dr. Alyssa Jones of Wilder Research presented a matrix of six focus areas with multiple research questions and methods for the DSI business licensing audit. Initial focus areas related to cost, compliance, workload, staffing, customer experience, and efficiency improvements. The committee deliberated on narrowing the scope due to budget and time constraints, emphasizing customer experience, staffing, and the creation of a user-friendly process map. Discussion also touched on avoiding overlap with other ongoing DSI studies and considering specific license types (Class R and T) over others (Class N). There was a strong interest in understanding 'nightmare scenarios' or outliers in license processing times.
Capstone Paper Update on Audit Committee Future
Dissent: None
Moved by Chair Naker [25:01] (suggestion for future action) · Seconded by CM Johnson [27:30] (agreement for future discussion)
Mr. McVey presented a memo outlining findings from his capstone paper on the future of the Audit Committee. He highlighted the importance of institutional independence, the need for permanent in-house staffing for continuous oversight and follow-up on recommendations, and the potential benefit of re-establishing an elected Comptroller function for pre-audit financial controls. He described models for staffing, suggesting a lean model of two FTEs or an intermediate model of three, up to five FTEs, to significantly increase audit throughput and proactive risk engagement. The committee members expressed strong appreciation for the work and indicated the need for further, in-depth discussion in the new year.
Notable Quotes (6)
I know from the city side sometimes the best um conversations relate to the staffing and staffing that um like so I guess number like number four uh I think on this um is like I'm looking at the staffing levels and the gaps and I'm just thinking about like how like poly the poly system coming up in place from 25 to 26 and thinking if it might be worth like also um like evaluating whether or not even going like maybe a year back or so like I'm thinking about like before Polly and then with the cyber attack and with Polly I just think like coming up off the ground that this might look different. you just had a drop off I think of like of DSI processing overall in 2025 that might be in a little bit of an anomaly.
I think it would also address a concern that I hear a lot, which is that um applicants get told that they need different things at different times in the journey and they think they're done and then all of a sudden they find out they need more. And to have that clearly graphically illustrated so that everyone can look at it and ideally say to themselves, this is the point at which we ask for all of the information and then this is the point at which it's all submitted and we don't keep going in circles and it's not iterative would would be helpful
I definitely think we need to as much as possible focus on customer interfacing because that is something that comes up a lot from, uh, just St. Paulites when I meet with them.
when we're taking that legal advice and using that to very narrowly define how we're scoping our audit, we shouldn't be necessarily using legal advice to frame audits. They should be there to guide audits. And so when we're using legal advice from an executive branch entity that could potentially we will audit at some point to frame our scope for our engagements that is a problem in terms of our independence as an institution.
We issue reports but we aren't always able to follow up with departments to see how they're going with implementation and whether they are correctively acting on or like if they're issuing corrective action plans with regards to our findings and recommendations. We don't have the capacity to do that currently and we for staff.
in the long run [clears throat] we should also look at potentially amending the city charter and actually having a comproller function again to do period audit controls over accounts payable and financial reporting.
Ordinances & Resolutions (8)
The primary subject of the audit study proposed by Wilder Research.
A research paper by Committee member McVey evaluating the Audit Committee's arrangements and proposing future models.
A new licensing system used by DSI, which is not yet ripe for full auditing but can be referenced for process comparisons.
Administratively approved business license type, a potential focus area for the audit.
Temporary business license type, a preferred focus area for the audit due to high interest in processing improvements.
Business license type requiring public notice, excluded from this audit as it's covered by another DSI study.
An ongoing study by the Mayor's office examining DSI's business licensing, specifically Class N licenses.
The foundational document of the city government, proposed to be amended to re-establish a Comptroller function.