St. Paul City Council — Transcript

Wednesday, August 19, 2026

2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation

Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

Votes (1)

2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

No formal action taken; presentation and discussion only.

Dissent: Vice Chair Yang expressed strong opposition to cuts to libraries, recreation centers, and the elimination of the CARES team. Council Member Kim questioned the efficacy of police academy funding without addressing broader hiring challenges and the uneven application of budget reduction targets. Council Member Buouie inquired about the performance of the alley pilot program and proposed stricter controls on overtime spending. Chair Johnson voiced concerns about the consistent under-budgeting for legal settlements and suggested re-evaluating municipal insurance.

The meeting encompassed a comprehensive presentation of the Mayor's 2027 proposed operating budget, focusing on strategies to close a $26 million general fund gap, including a 6.8% property tax levy increase, departmental spending reductions, and new revenue streams. Specific proposals included the elimination of the Fire Department's CARES division, the closure of Dayton's Bluff Library, reductions in police command staff, and investments in emergency services and deferred maintenance. The subsequent Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals report highlighted current financial performance, noting challenges in revenue collection for DSI and Public Works. Council members raised critical questions on the rationale and impact of various budget cuts, the sustainability of funding for key services, police hiring effectiveness, overtime management, and the city’s overall financial risk management for legal settlements and new revenue generation opportunities.

Notable Quotes (8)

My name is Maline Mitchell. I'm the city's budget manager and today I'm going to walk you through the mayor's 2027 proposed budget. We will start um with the overall budget picture, including the $26 million general fund gap that you've all heard about and how the proposed budget closes that gap.

Maline Mitchell, Budget Manager [00:03]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

At the highest level, the 2027 proposed operating budget is approximately $888 million. This includes a 6.8% property tax levy increase. It funds nearly 3,200 FTEEs and its development was guided by four principles laid out by the mayor's office. Uh promoting long-term fiscal sustainability, strengthening community safety, supporting a thriving business environment, and responding effectively to residents needs.

Maline Mitchell, Budget Manager [00:03]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

When we talk about balancing the budget or closing the budget gap, we have three le levers to pull to get that gap to zero. We can either increase the property tax levy, reduce spending, or find new non-propy tax revenue. [...] So that really leaves property taxes and spending reductions as our most powerful tools for balancing the budget.

Maline Mitchell, Budget Manager [00:03]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

Um, I just am wondering, you know, I noticed as we go through there's the 4% reduction target and there's the counted towards target. Um, and they vary greatly in some departments. So like some departments are right on target, above target in some cases and then some are are significantly under. Could you share a little bit about like what went into just thinking like it seems like there was a 4% reduction target but then what actually was given in some cases could be millions plus lower.

Council Member Kim [00:15]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

I am very concerned about just the like what what happens if we were to eliminate the CARES team. This is a team that we fought very hard to um to fund and and preserve from last year. Um to me like what's missing is really understanding the county's role in this and even the state too. what is the long-term vision for this?

Vice Chair Yang [00:24]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

On DSI specifically, we have experienced some significant difficulties with uh invoicing for revenue that occurred either right before or during the cyber incident last year and then we did the transition to poly. So we have it's been a priority of OFS to partner with DSI to set up a structure and process to collect the revenue that is due to the city for services rendered.

Joe Harney, Director of Financial Services [00:29]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

It turns out that you cannot convert loonies and tunis at any bank even if it's a Canadian bank in the United States that you literally quite literally need to drive to Canada with coins and go to a Canadian bank in order to convert that to US currency. [...] so through the course of many years of operating the Komo Zoo and the donation box, we as OFS have been tracking um what amounts to be approximately $10,000, I'll get you an exact number of just coins in foreign currency that we can't necessarily use as a on a cash basis in this country.

Joe Harney, Director of Financial Services [00:31]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

I'd like to understand what the fiscally responsible recommendation from the Office of Financial Services would be if we took into account the growing trends that are happening nationwide, especially taking into the account that the city of St. Paul does not have insurance like other municipalities. [...] when we have multi-million dollar lawsuits for years, my quick question to us is should we check that costbenefit analysis again this year.

Chair Johnson [00:35]
2027 Proposed Operating Budget Presentation and Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals Report

Ordinances & Resolutions (6)

Mayor's 2027 Proposed BudgetPlan

The comprehensive financial plan for the city's operations in the fiscal year 2027, presented by the Budget Manager.

2026 budget cycleOther

The previous budget period, used as a reference for comparison, projections, and the phase-off of ARP funds.

Q2 2026 Budget to Actuals ReportReport

A financial report comparing actual expenditures and revenues against the adopted budget for the second quarter of 2026.

ARP (American Rescue Plan)Other

Federal funding that is expiring, leading to reabsorption of costs and shifts of positions to the general fund.

Parks Safety AuditReport

Recommendations from this audit informed a one-time investment in safety technology for the Parks Department.

Budget BookOther

The detailed document containing comprehensive budget information, referenced for additional details on revenues.

View Source
St. Paul City Council - St Paul Recorder