St. Paul City Council — Transcript

Wednesday, August 5, 2026

Tenant Right to Repair Ballot Question

Deputy City Clerk Classification

Golf Course Ordinance Amendments

Mixed Municipal Solid Waste Contracts

Vacant Building Registration Appeal

Votes (5)

Resolution 26-1253: Directing the City Clerk to place a ballot question on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot regarding allowing tenants to make repairs to their building.

2 in favor, 5 opposed. The resolution fails.

Dissent: Bowie, Coleman; Johnson; Joest; Council President Laker voted against.

Moved by Vice President Yang [0:6:14] · Seconded by Not explicitly stated

The discussion centered on a memo from the City Attorney's office advising on conflicts between the proposed ordinance language and state law, potentially creating risk for the city. Supporters, like Vice President Yang and Councilmember Kim, emphasized the importance of democratic engagement through ballot initiatives and voters' capacity to decide, noting Duluth's similar successful ordinance. Opponents, including Councilmembers Johnson, Joest, and Council President Laker, focused on the legal flaws, enforceability issues, and the disingenuousness of putting an unconstitutional or vague item on the ballot, which could mislead tenants and expose the city to legal risks. They highlighted that differences between municipalities mean ordinances cannot simply be copied. The council president expressed shared values for tenant protections but emphasized concerns about the specific language.

Ordinance 26-35: Amending chapter 65 of the legislative code pertaining to golf courses.

7 in favor, none opposed. The ordinance is adopted.

Moved by Ms. Joest [0:16:32] · Seconded by Not explicitly stated

Councilmember Jost introduced the motion, highlighting that the ordinance modifies existing code to remove prohibitions on miniature golf and allows for night lighting at golf courses, specifically mentioning the Highland National Driving Range. The changes are intended to expand programming and increase revenue for the city.

Ordinance 26-36: Adding chapter 86.13 to the administrative code to require city council approval of mixed municipal solid waste contracts.

7 in favor, none opposed. The ordinance is adopted.

Moved by Council President Laker [0:18:27] · Seconded by Not explicitly stated

The motion for approval was made with thanks to legislative aide Megan Jacke, the city attorney's office, and the West 7th Fort Road Federation for their contributions.

Ordinance 26-27: Administrative ordinance placing the classification title Deputy City Clerk in the unclassified service.

7 in favor, none opposed. Public hearing is closed. The ordinance is laid over till August 12th for final adoption.

Moved by Council President Laker [0:26:40] · Seconded by Not explicitly stated

This public hearing featured strong opposition from union representatives (AFSCME Clerical Local 2508, PEA). Chelsea Berry, Kristin Kojal, Paul Tishler, and Tom Bastian testified against making the Deputy City Clerk an appointed, non-represented position, arguing it removes a union job, that union employees are capable of high-level work, and that previous Deputy City Clerks were union-represented. They contested the claim that signing authority necessitates an appointed role and urged the council to maintain union representation. The item was laid over for future adoption.

Resolution RLH VBR 26-14: Appeal of Deegan Goytom ACMN Properties LLC to a vacant building registration renewal requirement at 1047 Arcade Street.

7 in favor, none opposed. The legislative hearing's recommendation is adopted.

Moved by Vice President Yang [0:52:19] · Seconded by Not explicitly stated

The property, registered as vacant since 2022, was inadvertently changed from Category Two to Category One, reducing the fee. Ms. Mormann, the legislative hearing officer, recommended denying the appeal but granting a 90-day waiver, contingent on completing code compliance. Angela Dawson, representing ACMN Properties, confirmed future plans for a licensed cannabis grow operation and expressed frustration with the 'Polly' system for permit issues, which Council members acknowledged hearing from others.

Notable Quotes (12)

I really urge you to leave it to our voters. I hold our St. Paul voters capable of being able to cast a vote letting us know where they stand on this initiative.

Vice President Yang [0:6:14]
Resolution 26-1253: Directing the City Clerk to place a ballot question on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot regarding allowing tenants to make repairs to their building.

It was seen to potentially violate the United States Constitution in different areas. And it also was deemed to unconstitutionally avoid um for vagueness in the ordinance written as is.

Ms. Johnson [0:7:33]
Resolution 26-1253: Directing the City Clerk to place a ballot question on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot regarding allowing tenants to make repairs to their building.

But for me this is about the concerns around the legalities of the language that's coming before before us and could potentially go to the voters because if the voters, when they vote on it, um and they're voting yes, they're voting no, if it passes, the voters expect it to be implemented um and we wouldn't, you know, if we have a petition where we have language that's conflicting with other laws and we cannot meet what is expected when um folks are going to be voting on it, then that doesn't uh that doesn't serve uh the purpose and it doesn't serve the the job that we do.

Ms. Joest [0:9:41]
Resolution 26-1253: Directing the City Clerk to place a ballot question on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot regarding allowing tenants to make repairs to their building.

Personally, we're pretty big fish in the city. I think there are ways that on the front end we think the sky's going to fall and in the end it ends up being okay. So for me this is a risk that I'm willing to take on behalf of tenants in the city and I'm looking forward to supporting the motion.

Ms. Kim [0:10:49]
Resolution 26-1253: Directing the City Clerk to place a ballot question on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot regarding allowing tenants to make repairs to their building.

I don't want as Councilmember Johnson said, I think really well, for tenants to believe that something is the case but actually we can't implement or enforce. Not to mention the legal risk that it sounds like we open ourselves up to.

Council President Laker [0:13:3]
Resolution 26-1253: Directing the City Clerk to place a ballot question on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot regarding allowing tenants to make repairs to their building.

It's basically modifying the language in our code around golf courses where there was language that you could not have miniature golf and also that golf courses could not be lighted for night use and now we're changing that language to remove the part where you can't have miniature golf courses and also that golf courses that are equipped for lighting which in this case right now would apply to the Highland National Driving Range. They can operate until 10:00 p.m. And so really excited to see this come forth. This is going to be expanding programming at the golf course. So that you know, more folks can can come out and use it and also adding to the the revenue that we'll be receiving as a city for [clears throat] that additional programming. And so I'm really excited to open up the golf course even more to our entire community.

Ms. Joest [0:16:53]
Ordinance 26-35: Amending chapter 65 of the legislative code pertaining to golf courses.

This position would do work that is currently done by a union employee. This will result in the loss of a union job, and the Deputy Clerk role should remain as a civil service position to allow for greater continuity of service in the Clerk's office.

Chelsea Berry [0:21:40]
Ordinance 26-27: Administrative ordinance placing the classification title Deputy City Clerk in the unclassified service.

Asking union employees to compromise their values and leave a union job at the promise of more pay is at its most charitable a textbook example of union busting and more bluntly should be considered elitist and classist.

Kristin Kojal [0:23:43]
Ordinance 26-27: Administrative ordinance placing the classification title Deputy City Clerk in the unclassified service.

A higher level position with the appropriate authority, compensation, and accountability can still be a union position as seen by the various levels of of various high-level manager positions within the St. Paul Supervisors Organization.

Paul Tishler [0:25:21]
Ordinance 26-27: Administrative ordinance placing the classification title Deputy City Clerk in the unclassified service.

My recommendation to the council is to give a 3-month waiver on the vacant building fee in which if they've completed getting their code compliance certificate, there would be no vacant building fee for the 26-27 cycle. If they fail to complete the work, then there would be a vacant building fee forthcoming.

Ms. Mormann [0:46:16]
Resolution RLH VBR 26-14: Appeal of Deegan Goytom ACMN Properties LLC to a vacant building registration renewal requirement at 1047 Arcade Street.

I am actually planning on renting this property for a licensed cannabis grow that I am a licensed cannabis farmer. I've been farming hemp and cannabis for the past uh 7 years in northern Minnesota. I'm bringing the operation to the city.

Angela Dawson [0:48:47]
Resolution RLH VBR 26-14: Appeal of Deegan Goytom ACMN Properties LLC to a vacant building registration renewal requirement at 1047 Arcade Street.

I hear your concerns about Polly. It's very consistent with what I've heard from other folks too. Not just even related to legislative hearing items, you know, other things as well. And so I will be sure to have a conversation with our director of in our Department of Safety and Inspections about that because there are definitely areas of improvement for Polly overall.

Vice President Yang [0:51:5]
Resolution RLH VBR 26-14: Appeal of Deegan Goytom ACMN Properties LLC to a vacant building registration renewal requirement at 1047 Arcade Street.

Ordinances & Resolutions (23)

Resolution 26-1253Resolution

Directing City Clerk to place a ballot question regarding tenant repairs on the November 3rd, 2026 ballot.

Ordinance 26-35Ordinance

Amending chapter 65 of the legislative code pertaining to golf courses (miniature golf, night lighting).

Ordinance 26-36Ordinance

Adding chapter 86.13 to the administrative code to require city council approval of mixed municipal solid waste contracts.

Ordinance 26-27Ordinance

Administrative ordinance placing the classification title Deputy City Clerk in the unclassified service.

Ordinance 26-31Ordinance

Amending section 224.05c of the legislative code to eliminate the city's provisional 90-day minimum wage rate for workers between 14 and 17.

Resolution 26-167Resolution

Amending the start budget to include a one-time transfer of $400,000 from the Housing and Redevelopment Authority Enterprise Fund for the Commercial Corridors Program.

Resolution 26-132Resolution

Authorizing Parks and Recreation to amend financing and spending plan by $250,000 to accept local trail connections grant funds from the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources.

Resolution 26-160Resolution

Amending the Parks and Recreation 2026 Grant and Aid Fund for a $2,285,000 donation from Como Friends for Como Zoo and Marjorie McNeely Conservatory.

Resolution 26-162Resolution

Authorizing the Police Department to accept a $35,000 donation from the Saint Paul Police Foundation.

Resolution 26-164Resolution

Authorizing the Police Department to amend the 2026 grant and activity budget by $25,000 for the 2025 port security grant.

Resolution 26-163Resolution

Amending the budget for the City Council Office Renovation Project and approving the internal loan document.

Resolution 26-170Resolution

Authorizing the acceptance of $50,000 in grant funding from the Rocky Mountain Institute for two curbside EV chargers.

Resolution 26-157Resolution

Amending Fire Department financing and spending plans by $202.88 for a donation from the Saint Paul Fire Foundation to support the Fire Explorers program.

Resolution 26-165Resolution

Authorizing the city, through its fire department, to amend a joint powers agreement with the State Fire Marshal Division for a hazardous materials response learning and response team, with a $360,000 budget amendment.

Resolution 26-168Resolution

Authorizing the fire department to amend financing and spending plans by $500,000 for training and equipment for the Minnesota Air Rescue Team.

Resolution 26-173Resolution

Amending Fire Department financing and spending plans by $21,131.47 for Minnesota Task Force One reimbursement from the City of Edina.

Resolution 26-161Resolution

Approving a sound level variance for One Simple Plan for an India Fest 2026 event.

Resolution 26-172Resolution

Approving a sound level variance for Wabasha Brewing Company for a music event series.

RLH VBR 26-14Other

Appeal of Deegan Goytom ACMN Properties LLC to a vacant building registration renewal requirement at 1047 Arcade Street.

City of St. Paul Charter, section 12.03.2HOther

Referenced in discussion of Deputy City Clerk classification.

Chapter 65 of the legislative codeOther

Pertaining to golf courses.

Chapter 86.13 to the administrative codeOther

New chapter requiring city council approval of mixed municipal solid waste contracts.

Section 224.05c of the legislative codeOther

Related to minimum wage rate.

View Source
St. Paul City Council - St Paul Recorder