Edina City Council — Transcript

Wednesday, October 15, 2025

Story

Edina pauses housing plan for 4.8-acre fire station parcel

Property Tax Burden and Municipal Financial Sustainability

Land Use, Zoning, and Access Challenges

Alternative Development Opportunities: Microgrids and Energy Infrastructure

Neighboring Property Concerns and Community Impact

Votes (1)

Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

No formal vote recorded. The meeting was a work session for discussion and direction-setting. Consensus emerged to: (1) Conduct an independent property appraisal; (2) Broaden the RFP framework to explore multiple uses (not limited to residential); (3) Address legal/access issues and neighboring property impacts; (4) Return to the HRA with a revised RFP framework in January 2026.

Dissent: One commissioner explicitly stated inability to support an RFP for a landlocked 4.8-acre parcel without resolving legal access issues. Multiple commissioners expressed concerns about the narrowness of the residential-focused RFP and the lack of consideration for property valuation and broader fiscal strategy. No commissioner voiced strong support for proceeding with the RFP as originally presented.

Staff presented a proposal to issue an RFP seeking residential development aligned with city comprehensive plan, budget pillars (equity, health, sustainability, stewardship, engagement), and affordable housing goals. The RFP framework would require proposals to address affordability mechanisms (deed restrictions, community land trusts, ground leases), sustainable construction, bike/pedestrian connectivity, wetland enhancement, and post-construction tax value. However, multiple commissioners expressed concerns that the RFP scope was premature and too narrowly focused on residential/affordable housing without first: (1) obtaining an independent property appraisal to establish market value; (2) exploring alternative uses and broader development possibilities; (3) considering the property's potential to generate revenue for tax relief; and (4) addressing critical legal/access issues related to the 4.8-acre subdivision. Commissioners also raised concerns about neighboring property impacts and suggested exploring alternative uses such as microgrid infrastructure. The consensus emerged to pause the RFP process and first conduct a property appraisal and broader scoping exercise.

Notable Quotes (9)

We work within the parameters of visions and plans that have been approved by the city council and the HRA. So we try to carry forth those visions that have been in these fully vetted plans that had a lot of community process. And so if it's not in the plan we will I wouldn't bring it forward to you as a concept or an idea unless directed otherwise.

Director Stephanie Hockinson [Early presentation]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

My understanding is that one of the asks is that we approve moving forward with issuing an RFP to develop the land that will be a landlocked parcel 4.8 acres in size. And I need to say very clearly, I can't support that.

Commissioner [Name not clearly identified, discussing legal access issue]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

I don't think I've ever had so many letters from our residents concerned about property tax increases... I think we have to know what the property's worth on the retail market... And then use that money to keep our residents taxes down or... I think we need to frame it up a little bit broader way from a foundational sort of standpoint before we head for an RFP on housing only because I think we've got these other responsibilities.

Commissioner [Chair or senior member, discussing property tax concerns]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

I was going to go back to slide two... I do think we need a bigger. We need to cast a wider net. And... I don't think we should go for it with an RFP that is positioning us to only those kinds of outcomes... I think we need to cast a wider net. And personally, I think we should be looking holistically at how we stabilize our general levy.

Commissioner [Discussing broader land use options]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

I have a feeling that really top economic times are coming... So what does that look like? It's a scale, right? Balance on the one hand. We're going to be facing pressures for our city budget. On the other hand, the need for affordable housing is going to skyrocket because we're going to have a lot of unemployment coming forward... So how do we put that balance together in the use of this land?

Commissioner [Discussing economic uncertainty and housing need]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

Microgrids are paired with fire stations so that when the power is out, you have more security in terms of your energy. It is a way to mitigate rising costs of electricity... It seems the city would own and manage or we would sell it and have someone do that... There are grants out there for them... I think it could add value to any sale price that we might want to pursue... I do think it's an idea that is really worth pursuing.

Commissioner [Discussing microgrid opportunity]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

I went out to the land yesterday. It really does not feel like you're surrounded. All of the buildings are facing their backs to this land... I could see there being concerned with people cutting through parking lots... There's a lot of things that really do concern me about. I would not want an RFP to go forward that was super residential focused.

Commissioner [Discussing neighboring property concerns]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

I remember Council members Staunton saying. This will be really good for the property owners of e dina because it's a way we'll be able to keep taxes low. And the problem is as we've added buildings, density... why did we do this? It's seven stories high and it was zoned for four and two stories... And then I said, but we tifted and he nearly fell off his chair... we keep tipping multifamily.

Commissioner [Discussing property tax and density trade-offs]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

I think to me that those are the what we want to call next steps or whatever appraise the property. And we want to frame in RFP. And then the content of what's in there, right? We could discuss that general in general.

Commissioner [Summarizing next steps]
Request for Proposal (RFP) Framework for Fire Station No. 2 Outparcel Development

Ordinances & Resolutions (10)

Comprehensive PlanPlan

City planning document that guides land use; specifies the parcel as office/residential. Referenced as the foundational framework for all development decisions.

Zoning Study and Zoning UpdatePlan

Ongoing process to align zoning with comprehensive plan guidance. The parcel is currently zoned planned industrial but guided for office/residential.

Self Health District PlanPlan

Referenced as supporting residential development alignment with city plans.

Climate Action PlanPlan

Referenced as supporting residential development alignment with city plans.

City Council Resolution (July, year not specified)Resolution

Authorized the HRA to conduct discussions on behalf of the city regarding the parcel; final decision authority remains with city council.

Quality of Life SurveyOther

Survey data showing 61% of residents report too little affordable housing for singles and families; affordable housing listed as one of top four issues facing the city.

Budget Pillars and Work Plan (2025)Plan

Includes 'Livable City' pillar with focus on advancing affordable housing goals and increasing housing options. Guides staff project selection and evaluation.

Minnesota Statute (cartway easement requirement)Other

Requires minimum 5-acre parcel for cartway easement creation; the 4.8-acre subdivision would not meet this threshold, creating legal access challenges.

Sketch Plan (March 2023, BKB presentation)Plan

Conceptual plan presented during Fire Station No. 2 planning; included residential development concept on the outparcel with internal street and green space preservation.

Idina Housing Foundation Proposal (August, year not specified)Other

Housing foundation proposed RFP process for the site; presented conceptual massing and housing types to HRA.

View Source
Edina City Council - Edina Recorder