Edina Planning Commission approves accessory dwelling unit variance
The Edina Planning Commission unanimously approved a variance request on May 14 that will allow a professional photographer to build a small apartment attached to his garage, despite the structure being closer to his rear property line than city rules typically allow. The 8-0 vote clears the way for Andrew Vic to relocate his photography studio from St. Louis Park to his home in the Todd Park neighborhood.
Vic, who has owned the property at 5120 44th Street West for 22 years, requested permission to build an accessory dwelling unit (ADU) just 6.5 feet from his rear property line, rather than the required 12 feet. The variance was necessary because the property is constrained by unusual front-yard setback requirements that limit where he can build.
Commissioners praised Vic's design approach, which places the lower-height section of the structure closer to the property line while setting the two-story portion back 16 feet—exceeding the standard requirement. "The fact that you adapted the design to make sure that the part that was infringing on the setback requirement was a lower height was kind of the factor that tipped the scales," Commissioner Felt said.
Vic's wife, Janelle, told commissioners they had hand-delivered project renderings to neighbors and met in person with adjacent property owners, who expressed support. The railroad right-of-way behind the property also minimized concerns about neighbor impact, commissioners noted. Chair Bennett called the project "such a beautiful piece that fits in a complicated puzzle."
In other business, Commissioner Felt raised concerns about the city's work-from-home zoning rules, which restrict non-resident workers and limit client visits to 10 per day. She suggested the ordinance may need updating to reflect post-pandemic changes in remote work, including collaborative projects where workers may not all be residents. Staff indicated the review would be incorporated into a broader code update process. The commission also received updates on City Council approvals, including the Opus office building at 5100 Eden Avenue, which was approved with conditions requiring stone building materials on the first level and improved pedestrian connectivity.
Our proprietary artificial intelligence agent analyzed publicly available documents including meeting agendas, minutes, and transcripts to write this story to help inform local residents. Feedback helps us improve, so please consider rating how we did with the thumbs up or down below.
Other Topics from This Document
ADU Ordinance Implementation and Detached Structure Challenges
Work-from-Home Ordinance Review
Recent City Council Approvals and Development Updates
Also from this meeting
Edina considers shifting property assessment duties to county
Transition of Municipal Assessing Services to Hennepin CountyJun 13, 2026Edina Police Department's therapy dog Lou earns certification
Edina Police Department Therapy Dog CertificationJun 13, 2026Edina Approves New Library-Art Center, Eyes County Tax Services
Transition of Assessing Services to Hennepin CountyJun 11, 2026Edina's Oscam House Earns National Historic Register Designation
National Register of Historic Places Designation - Mari and Hendrick Oscam HouseJun 11, 2026Planning Commission Approves ADU Variance on 44th Street
May 15, 2025
Want to know when new stories arrive?
Enter your email to receive updates.
We will not use your email for any other purpose. You can unsubscribe at any time.