Peterson's Nomination Challenged by Council Over MPD Misconduct Questions
Interim Chief Billy Peterson faced intense scrutiny during confirmation hearings regarding his knowledge of racism and misconduct within the Minneapolis Police Department, ultimately leading to the City Council's rejection.
The Minneapolis City Council rejected the nomination of Interim Police Chief Billy Peterson on June 16, 2025, following nearly five hours of intense questioning that largely focused on his perceived lack of recall regarding incidents of racism and misconduct within the Minneapolis Police Department. The council's decision prompted Mayor Jacob Frey to defend Peterson's performance during the hearings, which he suggested was unfairly scrutinized given Peterson's long career.
During the extended questioning sessions, council members pressed Peterson on what he had witnessed or addressed regarding systemic issues of racism and misconduct during his tenure at the MPD. Council Members Jeremiah Ellison and Warren reportedly expressed shock at Peterson's inability to recall specific incidents, despite his decades of service.
Damn it, I forgot about the racist Christmas tree. That's what he said to me.
Mayor Frey later addressed Peterson's apparent memory lapses, recounting a conversation with the interim chief where Peterson acknowledged his oversight. The Mayor further defended Peterson, noting that he had also cited approximately ten discipline referrals he had personally made throughout his career, which were discussed during the questioning.
He's not a politician. You know who would have answered that question really well? Brian O'Hara.
Other Topics from This Document
City Council rejection of police chief nominee Billy Peterson
The mayor says the council voted down interim Chief Billy Peterson despite a 30-year record with no sustained complaints, letters of commendation and medals of valor. He calls the vote favoritism rather than governance and says no disqualifying infractions emerged.
Possible mayoral veto of the council's denial
Mayor says a veto decision must legally be made by Wednesday or Thursday of next week; he lacks the votes for a majority and criticizes members who indicated they'd vote yes only on a second round, calling it 'games.'
Interim leadership of the Minneapolis Police Department
Peterson remains interim chief 'for the foreseeable future,' but the mayor says it is Peterson's decision whether to continue or return to being inspector of the first precinct.
Police chief search and community engagement process
Process included engagement sessions in all five precincts, an interview panel, private and public meetings with every council member, and completion within a 16-week target. External candidates withdrew, leaving no qualified external finalists.
Mayor-council relations and public safety appointments
Mayor notes a second recent public-safety loss after the office of community safety commissioner matter, and says he lost votes from traditional allies; he declines to read too much into it.
Impact on MPD morale and recruitment of external candidates
Mayor says candidates have declined to apply citing 'toxicity' on the council, and warns of operational impacts and morale damage for months or years.
Want to know when new stories arrive?
Enter your email to receive updates.
We will not use your email for any other purpose. You can unsubscribe at any time.